Four years after power warnings, old engines still carry load


RePower Alice says the town was told by the Giles Government four years ago that the engines in the Ron Goodin power station had only a year to go.
Tim Brand, spokesman for the organisation which wants Alice to get 100% of its power from the sun by 2030, says the public was told by the CLP Government that the engines could not be maintained or upgraded, and would fail the town catastrophically very soon.
This has proved to be far from the truth, Mr Brand says.
Mr Giles, pictured above in the old power station with the unsuccessful candidate for Araluen, Steve Brown, made blackouts a major issue in lead-up to the 2016 election. (The photo appeared in the Centralian Advocate.)
The CLP spent $75m buying 10 gas powered generators for the Owen Springs power station instead of investing a significant part of that amount in more solar generation, as promoted by the town’s renewable energy lobbies.
Labor, then in Opposition, had little to say about this at the time, and has inherited what is clearly a mess.
Mr Brand says the old engines haven’t failed, as predicted: “Goodin is still working, is still used to power half the town.
“The surrounding residents in the upmarket Golfcourse Estate are still putting up with the noise, dust and smells.
“Somebody is talking bullshit.
“With elections ‘round the corner the Giles Government spent $75m without going to public tender or public consultation on 10 gas generators the community didn’t want and still don’t want.
“Contrary to spin in media releases, two of the 10 engines are still not commissioned, and the remainder are working only sporadically,” says Mr Brand.
“What is their use to this town? They seem to obsolete before they have been started working.
“Furthermore, the battery (at right) at Ron Goodin, also opened with fanfare more than a year ago, is still not working.
“Power Water Corporation changed the contract and the rules for the use of the equipment.
“Did Territory Generation (TGen) get the technology wrong in the first place? It is now being asked to provide reactive power to the grid but it’s not doing it, under the revised conditions Power Water Corporation are imposing now.
“One problem with this is, it’s necessary for the grid to have the need for reactive power [providing power briefly during blackouts] to test the battery and that has not occurred, which was clearly never accounted for by the battery supplier or TGen at the time of signing the contracts.”
Mr Brand says Power Water Corporation (PWC), which owns the town’s electricity wires network, won’t permit Territory Generation onto the grid to do the tests.
“As you will no doubt remember the BESS big battery in Alice Springs is required (according to PWC) to smooth out the fluctuations in solar production caused by small clouds,” says Mr Brand.
“Until this is commissioned the town is hamstrung by PWC and we are only allowed to have 25% of our power from solar, even if more is available.
“So instead of clouds being our biggest problem to electricity generation we are relying on a massive dirt, noisy, smelly, expensive gas generator at Ron Goodin.
“I wonder how this will reflect on your next electricity bill increases.”
The Alice Springs News is seeking comment from PWC and TGen.
Media manipulation by Adam Giles over blackout
Territory Generation rejects claims by electricity union
BESS jumps in when the sun doesn’t shine
UPDATE 1:15pm July 16
TGen CEO Tim Duignan provided this response:
Territory Generation is in the process of phasing out use of the Ron Goodin Power Station in Alice Springs, in the largest change to the local power generation system in 45 years.
The newly expanded Owen Springs Power Station together with the Battery Energy Storage Solution (BESS) will work together to provide reliability, efficiency and stability to the Alice Springs grid, as well as support renewable energy uptake.
The transition to Owen Springs Power Station has already started, with Ron Goodin Power Station to be put into ‘cold standby’, where no units are online but a number are kept in a ready state to respond as a contingency if required, in the second half of 2019. When Ron Goodin Power Station is moved into cold standby it will result in a drastically reduced carbon footprint for Territory Generation as it moves to gas-based generation at Owen Springs Power Station.
The same process took place in Tennant Creek in 2018, where Territory Generation proved it could be successfully completed. The new generators at Tennant Creek have greatly improved efficiency and have contributed to a significant carbon reduction.
Territory Generation’s BESS has been online since March 2019 and has been exceeding operational expectations. The BESS is a leading-edge 5MW system and is one of the largest grid-connected storage solutions in Australia.
The BESS works by storing energy for use when production exceeds consumption and releasing this energy into the system. In this way, it complements the Owen Springs Power Station by helping to smooth the output and impact of solar power in the system when consumption peaks or when the solar generation is interrupted by cloud cover.
Territory Generation has worked closely with Power and Water Corporation System Control to ensure the risk to the electricity supply in Alice Springs is as low as possible during this cautious testing and introduction phase.
Power and Water System Control has an obligation to ensure the system security in Alice Springs and they make operational adjustments all the time in all the regulated grids in the Northern Territory to meet their obligations. These adjustments relate to all generators operating in the systems, not just Territory Generation, as well as to Power and Water Corporation networks division to optimise the reliability and security of the entire system.


  1. How is the Brewer Estate Power Station still NOT operating?
    Since the arrival of the massive engine, which came by road from Darwin, I have: Had three jobs, got married, had two children the oldest of whom is eight, bought two houses, sold one house and moved to Sydney.
    All the meanwhile, the power station still isn’t operating?!

  2. More spin from Territory Generation!
    They announced that an upgraded power station for Alice Springs “will be complete by end of 2017” and then to shut Ron Goodin.
    Now that’s happening “in the second half of 2019”.
    They held an official opening of the Tennant Creek power station upgrade (with the then Minister McCarthy) in October 2017 announcing that the station would “commence operation over the next week”. Then the upgrade wasn’t ready and did not operate properly until almost 12 months later “in 2018”.
    Then officially they launched the big battery in November 2018, having originally announced “the Energy Storage System is expected to be complete by late 2017″.
    And now say it was online 5+ months later.
    How much have these repeated delays cost the Territory?
    And why does the government appointed board support such misleading announcements by the CEO?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here