Saturday, October 16, 2021

The freedom of the press still furnishes that check upon government which no constitution has ever been able to provide – Chicago Tribune.

HomeIssue 16A letter, a house and the gallery

A letter, a house and the gallery

By ERWIN CHLANDA

The chairman of the Alice Springs native title organisation Lhere Artepe (LA), Shane Lindner, is playing a role in events referred to in two sets of documents: One relates to the proposed National Aboriginal Art Gallery (NAAG) and the other to the allocation of funds for housing in East MacDonnells homelands.

LA says there is no connection between the two but this is questioned by a prominent political figure speaking with the News on the condition of not being named.

Mr Lindner signed a document on May 14 last year as the chairman of LA which he describes as “the representative of the Arrernte people”, the organisation speaking for the town’s three estate groups, holding native title over parts of Alice Springs.

They are notorious for feuding and internal strife although after a tumultuous meeting in March, an AGM has now taken place and a new board appointed, according to its former acting CEO, Graeme Smith, who has been given a three year contract.

The LA document was a letter to Chief Minister Michael Gunner and the then Minister for Families, Dale Wakefield: It confirmed LA’s support for NAAG “being located at the ANZAC Hill precinct, incorporating the ANZAC school and ANZAC oval sites”.

Mr Gunner, whilst claiming to have widely consulted on the issue, has not named any other Aboriginal sources in that process.

He wants the gallery built in the ANZAC precinct.

There is much anecdotal evidence that Arrernte people, possibly the majority, want the gallery south of The Gap instead.

This, it is said, is because they do not want their own culture to be impacted by outside ones.

Even the Queen felt compelled to seek permission from Aboriginal custodians to enter the town through The Gap. 

The Lindner letter is likely to be key evidence in the government’s imminent court action to compulsorily acquire ANZAC Oval from the Alice Springs Town Council.

Mr Lindner also features in a document of the Department of Territory Families, Housing and Communities, headed Scope of Works and dated March 11, 2021.

He is named, together with Bonnie King, as the tenants of an “improvised structure” in the Bottom Camp for which “an allowance of up to $390k has been set aside for a full demolition and replacement.

“Awaiting the outcome of further discussions,” says the document.

That amount is far more than what is planned to be spent on other dwellings in a scheme announced by Minister Chansey Paech to “improve safety of housing … through the Electrical and Fire Safety Maintenance Program across 131 homelands and 498 houses [to] improve the safety and conditions … by reducing the risk of electrocution, electrical fire [and] electrical hazards”.

Mr Paech trumpets on his Facebook site (pictured) his government’s construction of houses on communities, where occupiers are tenants of Territory Housing: “Each new home built in a remote community in the Northern Territory helps to reduce overcrowding and improve health and living conditions.” But there is no provision of housing on outstations and homelands, according to our source.

Building houses is not mentioned in Minister Paech’s media release on April 19.

According to the departmental document, expenditures per dwelling range from $8000 to $87,000. The highest, other than Mr Lindner’s, is $124,000.

No tenants other than Mr Lindner and Ms King are named in the document.

We asked LA: “Is there any connection between the letter of support, dated 14/05/2020, for the gallery location and the government funding for a house for Shane Lindner on his homeland east of Alice Springs?”

Mr Smith replied there is “no connection between the letter of support and house for Shane.

“First I’ve heard of it, actually. Whoever suggested this?”

An aide to Mr Paech provided a link to information online but when we tried to access it the answer we got was: “This grant could not be found, or you do not have permission to view it.”

The aide said: “Chansey is the relevant Minister in this instance however he is not involved in the specific allocation of housing works.”

She did not answer the following questions we put to Mr Paech on May 31:

Re: Remote and homelands housing program:

• Adam Giles did a deal in 2015 with the Federal Government for a one-off payment of $155m agreeing to take responsibility for of service delivery in homelands.

• Does that include housing maintenance, and if beyond repair, a new house will be built?

• How many houses were built since 2016 under that program? [Our source says none.]

• Is Lindner’s house the first to be built under that scheme?

• How many occupants are named on these contracts?

• When were contracts released which carried the names of the occupants?

We received no answer from Mr Gunner when we asked him on April 19: “Given that the NT Government rarely if ever pays for the building of houses on Aboriginal communities, for local residents’ use, how come your government is proposing to spend nearly $400,000 on a house for Shane Lindner who as the Lhere Artepe president presumably is signing off on the native title organisation’s consent for the art gallery to be built in the Anzac precinct – your preferred location?”

9 COMMENTS

  1. Native title has been extinguished at Anzac Hill, so it is beyond the jurisdiction of Lhere Artepe. The Gunner government is well aware of who the appropriate custodians for Mparntwe are, and has consulted with them.
    The result of the consultation was a resounding and unanimous “south of The Gap.”

  2. Thank you Larapinta, for cutting through the contemptible and divisive spin being used by Government to obscure the truth and deliberately mislead the public.

  3. Obvious grounds for an ICAC investigation. Hopefully those involved have reported it to the Commissioner.

  4. Maybe get facts before publishing, Erwin.
    This is a NTG, East MacDonnell Homelands Housing Upgrade program to which Shane was on the list of as a resident of the McDonnell Shire. Nothing to do with LAAC, but I know you try to stir the pot.
    Again, poor article which is misleading and lacking facts which further leads to misleading comments on the back of your article.
    Shane is also no longer LAAC Chair which I have told you.
    Larry Pinta at least understands the Native Title Act and lack of veto for native title holders within it, along with the extinguishment of Native Title at ANZAC Oval a long time ago.
    I ask Erwin, what is your agenda in providing such articles? The power of the pen!

  5. I do get my facts before publishing, Graeme.
    You say: “Shane is also no longer LAAC Chair which I have told you.”
    We report: “An AGM has now taken place and a new board appointed.”
    I’m reporting that the letter supporting Mr Gunner’s intention to build the gallery was signed by Mr Lindner as the “Lhere Artepe Aboriginal Corporation Chair” on May 14, 2020. Here is his signature on that letter:

    null

    I gave you the right of reply, you exercised it and I quoted you accurately.
    We describe the “NTG, East MacDonnell Homelands Housing Upgrade program” accurately.
    That “Shane was on the list of as a resident of the MacDonnell Shire” and that “Native Title Act and lack of Veto for native title holders within it, along with the extinguishment of Native Title at ANZAC Oval [happened] a long time ago” are not issues raised by the report.
    Was Mr Lindner on the housing list when he signed the letter to Mr Gunner?
    My agenda is to inform our readers, about 20,000 of them, independently measured by Google Analytics.
    Erwin Chlanda, Editor.

  6. Read your first sentence Erwin. very misleading. You do not refer to him as former Chair or make the comment of such, but rather go on to try and make the connection to a housing deal to which you have no idea … look at your title if not the first sentence.
    Your last sentence is words of no meaning in action. We want accurate reporting, not one sided. The town and readers deserve better quality, I’m afraid to say.
    You do raise the suggestion and connection between this and the Art Gallery and ILUA. Read your content. Nothing I have brought up or others. Entirely your thoughts.
    You have been corrected. Accept it!
    Will you publish the NT Government response in regards the housing program or will that not be made public? I note you published my comments, but not theirs. Hmmmm.

    ED – I stand by my report.
    On June 14 I emailed you: “Please bring me up to date about the office holders following the AGM and any important decisions.” You did not.
    I will publish answers from NT Government to our questions when the government provides them.
    Why don’t you answer my question: “Was Mr Lindner on the housing list when he signed the letter to Mr Gunner?”

  7. Larry and Graeme, who are the Mbantua Caterpillar people? Graeme please give us some names of your members. Please fill us traditional owners passed by the court which the Central Land Council organised all so called families which us Bray, Perkins, Turner are registered.
    While at it please supply the names and minutes of the last AGM. I fronted you in the office a few months ago in front of Mathew Palmer his brother Peter [Pumpkin] Palmer asked you who were the directors of Ilpma you named these two.
    Proof, please. When voted in.
    At that time you were handing out vouchers for fuel and food. On whose authority? On that day I asked for the chairman Shane Lindner and you told me he had resigned and moved onto work for a mining company other side of Tennant.
    Erwin, back in the day of Adam Giles I was invited by Mathew Palmer and Peter Palmer to meet with Giles at his office in Alice with two of his cronies. Mathew put it to Giles he wanted money to build a house on Corkwood. To make things short Giles told Mathew to see Scott McConnell who at that time was the CEO of Ingkerreke Corporation for we have given them $5m.
    If so where did this money go?

  8. Russel, if you don’t know who the mparntwe-arenye people are don’t bother asking Lhere Artepe cos they don’t want to know.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

error: Content is protected !!