Sunday, May 26, 2024

The freedom of the press still furnishes that check upon government which no constitution has ever been able to provide – Chicago Tribune.

HomeIssue 8The APY saga: Evidence suggests dysfunction

The APY saga: Evidence suggests dysfunction

2484 WatarruBy ERWIN CHLANDA
Further evidence has emerged suggesting the administration of APY Lands in the top end of South Australia is in turmoil, with senior staff apparently ignoring instructions from a special general meeting and an executive meeting.
These instructions included the termination of the appointment of the APY General Manager Richard King, who is still there, and gave strong indications that the executive wants  greater control over an extensive system of commercial agistment of cattle that is part of the APY’s activities.
The Alice Springs News Online has obtained copies of the minutes of the two meetings, and their content and authenticity has been confirmed by Bryan Miller, General Manager of the PY Ku Aboriginal Corporation which operates in the lands. (It owns and manages a network of remote transaction centres that combine service delivery for government agencies and access to technology for community.)
Mr Miller was present at one meeting and took the minutes for the second one.
The special general meeting on March 27 was attended by 35 people representing Ernabella, Fregon, Amata, Milily, Nyapari, Indulkana, Watinuma and Kalka and was presided over by then APY chairman Trevor Adamson. The chairmanship has since passed to Frank Young.
According to the minutes, the meeting resolved unanimously that Mr King “has failed to exercise a reasonable degree of care and diligence in the performance of his functions and that [his] appointment … be terminated, effective immediately”.
The issue was raised again in a special executive meeting of the APY on June 23.
Resolutions by seven executive members, present or on the ‘phone, with Mr Young in the chair, included these:–
• All staff and contractors of APY … including the ‘total grazing pressure’ cattle manager shall take direction from the APY chairperson … except to make advance payment (including cattle money) to or for the benefit of a member of the Executive board … not already authorised by the Minister under the APY Land Rights Act (1981)”.
• That “any issued retainers and permits concerning [six lawyers including Alice Springs based Ruth Morley] are terminated forthwith, and APY is not to continue to engage or pursue services from any of these people”.
• “The General Manager Richard King is reprimanded by the APY Executive board” for 12 named alleged acts or omissions.
• The meeting transferred several responsibilities from Mr King to Greg Jobson and appointed him Acting General Manager.
• The meeting suspended Mr King “pending further resolution without pay” and canceled his permit to be in the Lands.
The Alice Springs News Online put the issues raised in this report to Mr King and Ms Morley at 7:55am today.
Our email said: “The above is clearly in contradiction of Ms Morley’s assertion: ‘I warn you not to quote Frank Young wanting to dismiss Richard King as Chairman of the APY Executive Board. There is no resolution about this from the Executive Board. Such a statement is misrepresentative and defamatory’. In fact there are resolutions from a special general meeting and an executive meeting,” we said. “Your comment, please.”
And: “The minutes of the second meeting make it clear that cattle are in fact the business of APY, a statutory body of the SA Government, and as such obliged to transparency. Ms Morley’s statement ‘grazing on APY lands is commercially confidential and APY are under no obligation to disclose anything about it publicly’ is in conflict with that. Your comment, please.”
We have received no response by the time of publication, but will report any response that we receive.
Photo: Watarru community about 200 km south west of Uluru in the APY Lands of South Australia. (SA Department of Education.)


  1. Kyam Maher, SA Minister Aboriginal Affairs, has a great deal to answer for. He forced Richard King onto APY and threatens an administrator if he is sacked. In fact King is the administrator.
    Two Aboriginal people, Maher and King [rule over] grass roots Anangu – the poorest of the poor.
    We’ll have our day in court. APY Council of Elders won’t stop until justice is seen to have been done.

  2. These consequences flow from ongoing governments’ racist division achieved with local support for apartheid approaches to policy.
    Government’s response thus remains “government only does this to help you …”
    Clearly this not true, or else far more improvements should be visible.
    Consider more how the local supporters for these racist apartheid approaches provide so little improvement, leaving the APY little room to argue and negotiate.
    The best path to achieving equality of opportunity, and better measurable results, is for APY to join the rest of Australia and dump these out-of-date apartheid feudal approaches.

  3. Well done to Alice Springs News Online for investigating these issues and coming up with the facts in regard to the resolutions of the Special General Meeting and the Special Executive Meeting.
    Why has the SA Minister Mr Kyam Maher allowed General Manager Mr King to ignore the resolutions passed at these meetings?
    He was made aware of them. More media sources need to make these issues public.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

error: Content is protected !!