Town centre facelift would grind to a halt under Labor funding, says Mayor Ryan


Country Liberals suggest Labor “stuff-up”: Traeger Park TV lights are already there.
 
By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
Alice Springs will get only half as much as its Town Council asked for, and much later than expected.
This is the response by Mayor Damien Ryan to the campaign promises made by Chief Minister Paul Henderson last Friday.
Mayor Ryan says the council asked for $5m in 2012/13 to continue the town centre re-development, but will only get $2.5m, deferred and over two years, 2014 to 2016.
Labor, if re-elected, would spend the shortfall of $2.5m on broadcast-standard floodlights for Traeger Park oval – something that the council did not ask for.
Meanwhile the Country Liberal Member for Braitling, Adam Giles, says the Labor government announced in a press release in 2004 that lights suitable for TV coverage had been installed.
Says Mr Giles: “Labor has committed its $2.5m to ‘broadcast standard’ lights at Traeger Park.
“Is this an admission that they stuffed up last time as the last set of lights erected in 2004 or 2005 was supposed to be up to the required standard for night time television broadcast? See project information by GHD.”
Mayor Ryan says the council did ask for lights at Albrecht Oval but this isn’t in Mr Henderson’s current program.
Mayor Ryan says the first $5m from the government for the CBD facelift will be spent in this financial year.
“By Christmas the Parsons Street section will be done and by mid next year, the Todd Street section,” he says.
“It’s pretty disappointing that the CBD doesn’t rate before 2014-15 which is a long way away.
“We don’t have a rate base to be able to do this job and always saw it as needing NT Government investment.
“We as a council are disappointed. We would need to do stage two pretty quickly.
“You wouldn’t be able to start stage two with that small a commitment.
“Without funding we won’t be able to start stage two. We need to have the money in place.”
The council’s wish-list was given to both major parties. It included more mall re-development, plus an “all abilities” park, lights for Albrecht oval, and toilet blocks for Jim McConville, Frances Smith, Araluen and Head Street parks.
Mayor Ryan says under Labor funding it is unclear what, if anything, can be done in stage two, given the shortfall and the delay, putting into doubt the long-planned three-stage scheme to cost a total of $15m.
The Indigenous All Stars will play here in 2013, says Mayor Ryan, but he understands there have been plans to upgrade the Traeger Park lights for some time.
He says one of the existing two sets of lights could be put up at Albrecht Oval.
The council also asked for the Solar Cities project to be funded past the end of 2012-13 but this was not included in Mr Henderson’s commitments.
PHOTO: Market last Sunday in Todd Mall. Funding as announced by the Chief Minister would curtail further progress on the long planned town centre upgrade.

Missed the Henley battle of the big boats? Watch it here!

Henley on Thames, move over, you don’t need water to have a regatta!
Henley on Todd has been proving that since 1962 with an annual race of bottomless boats and rowers who are more fleet of foot than arm.
And to wrap it all up the big boats are launched for a spectacular sea battle in which locals – including captains of industry – come head to head to head as pirates and Vikings. And all that at least 1500 kms from a decent body of water. If you missed it watch it here!
Henley on Todd is run entirely on a volunteer basis by the three Rotary Clubs based in the Alice. The entire proceeds – well over a million dollars over the years – are allocated to local, national and international humanitarian projects. Images by ERWIN CHLANDA.

Chamber slams Labor promises: football instead of stimulating business

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
Labor’s election promises for Central Australia lack incentives for economic development in remote towns, give no thought to stimulating private enterprise in those areas, and by failing to allocate sufficient money to Alice Springs itself, fall short in returning the town to the tourist destination is used to be.
This is the view of Kay Eade, CEO of the Chamber of Commerce in Alice Springs, pictured at the Greatorex election forum she moderated, with (from left) ALP candidate Rowan Foley and Independent Phil Walcott.
She says money promised for football fields in bush communities would be better spent on stimulating business: “Why do electricians drive in and out from Alice Springs to service these communities?” she says.
“Why not provide incentives for setting up shop in a hub town, with the condition that apprentices are employed?
“Locals soon would develop their own enterprises rather than being told by outsiders what to do.”
Ms Eade questioned the value of the $2.5m upgrading of floodlights at Traeger Park: “How many nationally televised football matches would we get a year? One or two?
“At the end of the day, how much money would that bring into this town?”
She says while roadworks are welcome, it is unfortunate that the sealing of the Mereenie Loop is not proceeding.
It would be a major new attraction for the self-drive, grey nomad market which needs sealed roads for their mobile homes and caravans.
“We are missing out on a lot of money.
“The project has been in the Budget for the last three years that I know of,” she says.
Communities along the Loop Road would have major commercial opportunities flowing from increased tourism.
“There is no policy of assisting businesses and attracting investment at a time when the carbon tax will drive up freight and petrol prices,” says Ms Eade.

Labor would spend as much on a third set of footy oval lights as it would on the rest of Alice

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
The Territory Government, if re-elected next week, will spend as much on a third set of lights for Traeger Park as it will for the rest of the town.
Announcing election promises for Central Australia, Chief Minister Paul Henderson said in Alice Springs today it will cost $2.5m to upgrade the lights to broadcasting standard, so that AFL games such as the Indigenous All Stars can be broadcast nation-wide.
It will be available in 2014-15.
The same amount will be paid to the Town Council for the enhancement of the CBD and community parks. Mr Henderson says this will add to the $5m previously granted and now “earning interest in the bank”.
Of that only $1.5m will be available in 2014-15 and the rest in 2015-16.
More than $5m will be spent on upgrading schools “across Central Australia” – no details were given which schools.
A “Territory wide bush roads package” – no costs given – will include roads in the TiTree, Titjikala and Santa Teresa regions

but not the tourist road, the Mereenie Loop, between Alice Springs and King’s Canyon.
Mr Henderson said his government had already spent “tens of millions of dollars” on that road and there are now different priorities.
Yuendumu and Kintore (populations about 790 and 350, respectively) will get $1m each for sporting grounds. (These commitments give Labor candidates in both the bush seats, Namatjira and Stuart, something to play with.)
Claiming that the promises for Central Australia amounted to about $150m Mr Henderson clearly included a string of further projects in Centralian bush communities, including a $2m creche, a $6.4m “multi purpose youth facility” and $13m for housing at Ntaria, a $4.4m family centre and $13m for housing in Yuendumu, and $7m for upgrading health clinics at Papunya, Titjikala and Docker River.
When questioned, Mr Henderson conceded that most of that money will come from Canberra and the time frame was subject to negotiations, lease by lease.
He said all that expenditure would flow from an agreement with the Central Land Council for lease payments for land needed for government facilities – something he said the Country Liberals were opposed to.
What’s more, the Federal funds would be the result of his negotiations. There is little relevance to differentiate between NT and Federal spending, he said: some 80% of the NT Budget comes from Canberra in any case.
Asked what his government, if re-elected, would do to aid the ailing businesses of Alice Springs, Mr Henderson said he would not sack “one single public servant”.
Mr Henderson said there would be no further campaign announcements from the ALP about infrastructure spending in The Centre.
PHOTO: Mr Henderson (centre) during the announcement today. He is flanked by (from left) ALP candidates Adam Findlay (Araluen), Rowan Foley (Greatorex) and Deborah Rock (Braitling).
 
 
 
 
 

Home at last?

Two years after the debacle over the erection of a giant statue depicting explorer John McDouall Stuart, the Alice Springs Town Council and McDouall-Stuart Lodge no.219 announced this morning that they have agreed to locate the statue “which was gifted to Council by the Lodge” at the western end of Stuart Park on Stuart Terrace.
Further, council has made an an application to the Heritage Committee for approval of the placement, required because Stuart Park is part of the town’s Heritage Precinct. That committee will next meet in October.
In August 2010 Stuart Park was chosen as an alternative location to the Civic Centre lawns following controversy over the statue – its size and character and the fact that the explorer is depicted carrying a gun. Its creator, folk sculptor Mark Egan, is perhaps best known for his giant Anmatjere man, woman and child located at the Aileron Roadhouse.
The Stuart statue’s placement in Stuart Park was deferred when council realised it needed heritage approval for the site. The statue has been stored at an undisclosed location ever since.
Pictured: Masonic Grand Master for SA and NT, Brother Ray Clark together with Mayor Damien Ryan at the statue’s unveiling in August 2010. From the Alice Springs News archive.
 
From our archive:
 
Volume 17, Issue 28. August 12, 2010.
 
Stuart statue comes and goes 
 
By KIERAN FINNANE.
 
The veiled statue of John McDouall Stuart, explorer and Mason, was last Friday afternoon lowered by a crane into a temporary pedestal on the Town Council lawns, speeches were made, the statue duly unveiled and then it was taken away again.
A cheerful atmosphere prevailed even if the controversy over this gift to the community of Alice Springs occasionally rose to the surface.
Everyone played their part.
A phalanx of local Freemasons, in dark suits and Masonic regalia, stood at the edge of the gathering.
Brother Les Pilton, of the McDouall Stuart Lodge Number 219, introduced Mrs Betty Pearce, with an elevated reference as “the senior native title member of the Arrernte people”, who had “graciously offered to present a ‘welcome to country’”. (Mr Pilton is pictured below left, with Mrs Pearce standing behind him, together with Mayor Ryan and Mr Clark. From the Alice Springs News archive.)
Mrs Pearce spoke of the “pioneer spirit, the spirit of Alice Springs and how we need to be looking at our future … in the spirit of being together, advancing together”.
Her ideas in that direction were to have dual street names – “Central Arrernte names as well as white man, non-Aboriginal names so we can have an absolutely unique town”.
She also wanted to see an “Alice Springs Garden of History” created at Stuart Park with “busts and statues of all the other pioneers, the Aboriginal ones, the cameleers, the miners”.
“It would be our history and McDouall Stuart would be the first one to start that history off,” said Mrs Pearce, before she accompanied Mr Pilton to touch the still veiled statue with her walking stick.
Mrs Pearce also commented on the concerns expressed over the statue carrying a gun: “Well let’s face it, back in the old days and even in today’s days when people want to go out bush, hunting or looking for food, they carry guns.
And I know lots of Aboriginal people with licenses to go shooting and they get kangaroo and stuff like that. So really speaking, let’s forget about that gun and let it die.”
Brother Ron Ross played a Robbie Burns song on the bag pipes, “A man’s a man for all that”.
Mr Pilton described the gifting of the statue as “a risk taken by members of McDouall Stuart Lodge … just a group of people holding a belief that this explorer should be recognised. We got support in our belief by the townspeople we spoke to”.
He warned anyone considering building a statue that “the road is long and tough”.
“It seemed that the only opportunity to keep fit these last few weeks was to continually jump hurdles placed in the way.”
He thanked Mayor Damien Ryan and the council for the opportunity of presenting the statue, suppliers who had supported the cause, the SA and NT Grand Master who was here to do the unveiling and finally “our sculptor Mark Egan, a local lad, Territory born and bred”.
“To work with and alongside his creative genius is awe-inspiring. He has done us proud to have come this far and stick to the task when it appeared alas our labour was lost.”
Barry Skipsey sang a song composed by himself and Dave Evans about Stuart, called “What drives a man”.
“What a wonderful day, a beautiful day,” he said as he thanked the crowd for their applause.
Mayor Damien Ryan acknowledged, as he always does, “the Central Arrernte people who are the traditional owners and custodians of Alice Springs”.
He said the statue and ceremony will “help us mark the 150th anniversary of Stuart’s expedition through the Centre of Australia”.
He commented on a replica of “a stunning 19th century oil painting of John McDouall Stuart [that] was presented to the people of Alice Springs fittingly by Australia’s very first local government which was the City of Adelaide”, seeming to make a link between this uncontroversial gift and the one “being presented to our town by the Freemasons”, which he accepted “on behalf of the Alice Springs community”.
He spoke of the reasons why we remember Stuart – “his sense of determination and his explorer spirit … his commitment to Central Australia … I mean this is part of our heritage here in Central Australia”.
Ted Egan sang his song about Stuart, “Rider in the mirage” which will feature on his forthcoming album, but spoke first about Stuart and about his son, Mark, who had borne the brunt  of some of the criticism of the statue.
He said Mark had researched his subject and would not have undertaken the commission had there been evidence of aggression by Stuart towards Aboriginals.
“On the contrary,” said Mr Egan, “when confronted by the Waramungu at Attack Creek, he graciousy turned around and went back to Adelaide.
He did not want any confrontation.
“So the gun does not represent invasion, people who are using ‘invasion’ are using it very ill-advisedly.
“The gun represents the man who is struggling against the harsh interior and living off the land to try to cross this country.”
(For a different reading of what happened at Attack Creek, see Dick Kimber in Issue 1709 – search our foundation archive.)
It was almost time for the unveiling, done jointly by the Masonic Grand Master for SA and NT, Brother Ray Clark, together with the Mayor.
Mr Clark made his thankyous including to “the community of Alice Springs for allowing Freemasons to be involved in celebrations”.
PRIDE
He expressed pride in the fact “that many of our early pioneers such as Sir Charles Todd and John McDouall Stuart and other leading citizens of Alice Springs … were all Freemasons” and talked about the work in the community that Freemasonry does today.
He noted that it took Stuart, this “go-getter explorer”, five attempts to cross the continent and made a light-hearted reference to the controversy around the statue: “It will take a few attempts too for this statue to find its final destination.”
Until the actual unveiling all reference to the controversy came from those officially taking part in the ceremony.
Several people who had expressed concern over council’s processes around the gifting observed the ceremony without making their presence felt.
Another small group had held up a banner throughout the proceedings, reading “No room for racism”. Some of them, if not all, are associated with the Intervention Rollback Action Group, including activist Barbara Shaw who is standing for the Greens in Lingiari.
As the statue was unveiled to cheers and applause from the crowd there was some booing from this group and cries of “Shame on you!”.
As this persisted, Barry Skipsey urged the assembly to give three cheers for McDouall Stuart, which many did.
Proceedings over and a cold breeze blowing, the crowd soon dispersed and the crane moved back into place to take the statue away until the issues around its final location are resolved.
 

Below: Local Freemasons at the unveiling in August 2010. From the Alice Springs News archive.

 
Volume 17, Issue 28. August 12, 2010.
 
Stuart statue: Where to from here?
 
How confident can we be that the fiasco surrounding the yet-to-be-finalised erection of the statue of John McDouall Stuart will not be repeated?
There will be a review of the public art policy.
CEO Rex Mooney says this has been called for for some time by the Public Art Advisory Committee.
It will become a priority once the committee has finished dealing with the public art that is to be installed in the Aquatic and Leisure Centre, says Mr Mooney.
He mentions as an area of concern the clause relevant to the current controversy, dealing with gifting, saying that the intention behind the clause was to deal with gifting to the Public Art Collection and that statues are not mentioned.
He says statues are clearly public art, but there is a grey area in the policy concerning dealing with them.
Is council intending to remove this area from the purview of the committee or is it approaching the review with an open mind?
Mayor Damien Ryan says the intention is “trying to get something that everyone’s happy with”, commenting that council has reviewed a lot of things, such as the public places by-laws, and the subdivision and development guidelines.
Who’ll be contributing to the review?
The advisory committee and council, says Mr Mooney.
“If you’re asking if there are going to be any parameters set at the outset, there won’t be.”
It is both the council’s and the Freemasons’ intention that the Stuart statue finds its final home at the heritage-protected Stuart Park.
The Freemasons will be making the requisite application to the Heritage Minister, Gerry McCarthy, as part of the gifting process.
Once they have heritage approval “we’ll have to sign off on it as controllers of the land”, says Mr Ryan.
And what if they don’t gain approval?
“I’m not going down that track,” says Mr Ryan.
If there were any doubt, it became absolutely clear last Friday that the statue is not only in honour of Stuart the explorer, who was a Mason, but honours Freemasonry itself.
Three out of the four plaques to be affixed to the pedestal refer in some way to Freemasonry.
One understandably acknowledges the gift of the McDouall Stuart Lodge and the unveiling if it by the SA and NT Grand Master, Brother Ray Clark.
The one that gives Stuart’s life dates – 7th September 1815 to 5th June 1866 – does so under a Masonic symbol, even though Stuart was only inducted into Freemasonry a year before the 1860 expedition, as the crowd were informed by Brother Les Pilton last Friday.
A further plaque lists past members of the McDouall Stuart Lodge, 146 of them, many well-known names.
A question to Mr Ryan about whether council is concerned about this earns a lecture on Australian civic values.
“I find it really interesting that maybe some people who are born Australian don’t actually understand what [this] is about,” he says.
He then reads from information he refers to during citizenship ceremonies: “All Australians have a commitment to various values and institutions and these include parliamentary democracy, equality before the law, freedom of the individual, freedom of speech and religion, equality between men and women, equality of opportunity for all.”
“People who become citizens have to look into that before they do it,” says Mr Ryan.
“It seems that there are others out there who may not really understand that’s really a part of life. We live in a  multi-cultural town. A gift was made by somebody this year in relation to the 150th Anniversary.”
So how would council respond to a request to construct a monument from other groups?
Mr Ryan retorts: “I thought you were here to report the news, not to make the news. And when that happens, let’s discuss that issue.”
Mr Ryan clearly mistakes concerns about perceived special treatment by council for a particular interest group for an attack on freedom of speech and religion.
The Alice News attempts to move on to a question about potential conflict of interest.
Mr Ryan heads off any elaboration about the legitimacy of this question:
“That is what is so disappointing to me by the people reporting on this issue.
“There was no conflict of interest stated by any member of council.
“Now we do things in council every month and I accept that the people in there understand conflict of interest.
“That there’s been this driving point by certain journalists actually undermines the integrity of all the elected members.
“You’re saying they don’t understand conflict of interest and that is a disappointment to me.”
Actually not saying it, asking a question. Again he cuts the News off.
“No, no. They’d never ask that question on rubbish or something else.
“It’s been a driven point and I’ve not answered it up to this point because I’ve been so disillusioned that people who report on council wouldn’t actually see the integrity of the elected members who have the opportunity to issue their conflict of interest on any issue that goes to council. That’s the most disappointing fact.”

Bread & circuses in Darwin, crumbs in the bush: do the numbers

How ‘worthy’ is Hendo’s Big Nite In?
 
COMMENT by KIERAN FINNANE
 
Today, August 16, Territory Labor committed $10 million over four years to support local developments and initiatives in the Territory Growth Towns. It was billed by Chief Minister Paul Henderson (pictured on the ‘Team Henderson’ website with Minister for Central Australia Karl Hampton, in sunglasses) as a commitment to “build a better future for all Territorians, no matter where they live”.
But it’s worth doing the math to make sense of just how much of a “better future” the Chief Minister envisages for those Territorians who don’t live in Darwin and do live in the so-called Growth Towns. These are all mainly Aboriginal communities, mainly well off the Stuart Highway. There are 21 of them: Ali Curung, Angurugu, Borroloola, Daguragu/Kalkarindji, Elliott, Gali’winku, Gunbalanya, Lajamanu, Maningrida, Milingimbi, Ngukurr, Ntaria (archive photo below), Numbulwar, Papunya, Ramingining, Umbakumba, Wadeye, Wurrumiyanga (Ngui) where Mr Henderson made his announcement, Yirrkala and Yuendumu.
So, $10m divided by four years comes to $2.5m per year. Divide this by 21 and you get $119,048 per Growth Town.
This would be available “to deliver priority projects identified with our community reference groups in each town”, said Mr Henderson.
“For example, here in Wurrumiyanga this grant can be used towards worthy projects where there may be no other immediate source of funds.”
What would be considered a worthy project? Would it extend to “the very best entertainment, making the most of our great Territory lifestyle”? That’s apparently a worthy commitment to make in Darwin, where on August 12, Mr Henderson committed $500,000 annually “towards Hendo’s Big Nite In if the Henderson government is re-elected”.
“The event will cater for up to 6000 people in the 2013 Wet Season,” said Mr Henderson, “and feature a host of local and interstate bands as well as the international headline act, market stalls and other entertainment.
“Territorians will have a major role to play in selecting which International headline act performs at the launch of Hendo’s Big Nite In and we’ve set up a Facebook Page to receive suggestions.”
So, let’s do the population count for the Growth Towns, using 2006 figures from the Territory Government’s Working Future site:
Ali Curung – 440
Angurugu – 1045
Borroloola – 2,362
Daguragu/Kalkarindji – 1,011
Elliott – 488
Gali’winku – 2,290
Gunbalanya – 1,258
Lajamanu – 845
Maningrida – 2,781
Milingimbi – 1,141
Ngukurr – 1,137
Ntaria – 999
Numbulwar – 783
Papunya – 340
Ramingining – 828
Umbakumba – 459
Wadeye – 2,222
Wurrumiyanga (Ngui) – 1,543
Yirrkala – 990
Yuendumu – 794
Total population: 23,756. In many of these towns close to half the residents are under 20 years of age.
So in Darwin Hendo is promising $500,000 to benefit 6000 people a year – that’s $83.33 per head for “world class music acts” so that “our kids to have the same opportunities as others”. This is in addition to, as his announcement emphasised, the funding of the Territory’s biggest annual music festival, Bass in the Grass; building Hidden Valley into one of the best motorsport tracks in Australia attracting more than 110,000 spectators through the gate each year to first-class sporting events; introducing the V8 Supercars Race & Rock Concerts featuring world class acts such as INXS, Simple Plan, Jimmy Barnes, Grinspoon, Sneaky Sound System and Short Stack; and investing a record $1 million worth of annual funding to support the 2012 Darwin Festival.
In the Growth Towns he’s promising $2.5m a year to benefit 23,756 people – that $105.23 per head for “worthy projects”.

Car fuel: nice work if you can get it

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
Further details are coming to light about the high cost of automotive fuel in Alice Springs although the industry is still refusing to answer questions.
The informant mentioned in our report posted last week bought diesel on August 3 for about $1.53 a litre from an Alice Springs wholesaler.
According to FUELtrac the Terminal Gate Price (TPG) on that day in Adelaide was an average (across all companies) of $1.34.
The TPG is usually for full tanker loads (of at least 35,000 litres) for product paid cash on delivery (COD).
Transport to Alice Springs is believed to be 7 to 9 cents a litre. Assuming it’s 8 cents, that gives the wholesaler a margin of 11 cents a litre – three cents more than the retailer is getting.
That’s a mark-up of $3850 for the 35,000 litres, of course delivered in bulk.
The Alice Springs News Online has asked the wholesaler for a comment.

From Papunya to Paris: the interest in Western Desert art just keeps going

Papunya Tula artists at the National Gallery of Victoria last year with curator Judith Ryan. From left, they are Bobby West Tjupurrula, Long Jack Phillipus Tjakamarra, Ronnie Tjampitjinpa and Mike Tjakamarra. They are standing in front of a 1991 work by Ronnie Tjampitjinpa, Wartunuma.

 
By KIERAN FINNANE
 
A major exhibition on the origins of Western Desert art is set to open at the Musee du Quai Branly in Paris in October. Curated by Judith Ryan and Philipp Batty for the National Gallery of Victoria, Tjukurrtjanu opened in Melbourne last year, examining “a watershed moment in the history of art when a painting practice emerged at Papunya”. More than 160 of the first paintings produced there during 1971 and 1972 will be shown in Paris, together with almost 100 objects and photographs from the period. The Musee du Quai Branly’s website, describes the significance of the show thus: “By transposing to recycled wooden panels the motifs employed in ephemeral ritual paintings, the Aborigine [sic] artists of Papunya created an astonishingly inventive formal art, saturated with meaning. These works change the manner of understanding the territory and conceiving the history of Australian art.”
The Paris exhibition is just one of the events occurring in the second half of this year that gives Papunya Tula Artists – the desert’s oldest painting company and still the benchmark of independence and achievement – reason to be optimistic.
Along with the entire art market, the company has been experiencing a “cooling off”, says manager Paul Sweeney, but he sees it as a good thing. It has meant fewer people out there chasing artists to churn out paintings, and this has helped check the illusion in the minds of some artists “that everything they painted was gold”. Only in “a very few cases” has that been true, he says.
The rate of production has slowed, from around 300 works a month at the height of the market to a more manageable 100, yet there is still plenty of energy and commitment amongst artists as well as keen interest in their work by art lovers and collectors in Australia and around the world.
From hectic to just busy 
The galleries that represent the company interstate were telling them “that things were slowing down” well before they felt it in Alice Springs, says Mr Sweeney. While the pace has now gone from “hectic to just busy” which is “kinda nice”, the second half of the year is building to a certain tempo: “We’ve definitely not gone into our shells. We’re still doing the same number of shows.”
The celebrations to mark its 40th year will culminate with their annual show in Alice Springs, on the last Friday of November, into which “we’ll pour everything”, says Mr Sweeney. The Araluen Arts Centre will mark the occasion with a parallel exhibition, reflecting on the relationship of the people of Alice Springs with the company, showing works collected by locals over the decades.
Meanwhile, two of the company’s artists, the late Doreen Reid and the very much alive Warlimpirrnga Tjapaltjarri, are represented in the 13th Documenta in Kassel, Germany, showing until mid-September (installation pictured, with Reid’s work lying flat, Warlimpirrnga’s on the wall) . Documenta is a huge and eclectic art event that has been going since 1955 and is expected to attract up to 750,000 visitors. Among exhibits by some 300 artists, the “pulsating abstractions” of Warlimpirrnga attracted the eye of New York Times art critic Roberta Smith, who described them as “riveting”.
Works by some of the company’s most famous artists, past and present, feature in Ancestral Modern, showing at the Seattle Art Museum and drawing on the collection of Australian Aboriginal art by Margaret Levi and Robert Kaplan. It opened at the end of May and is still getting press notices, says Mr Sweeney. The artists represented are Richard Yukenbarri, George Ward, Makinti Napanangka, George Tjungurrayi, Ningura Napurrula, Yukultji Napangati, Eileen Napaltjarri, Doreen Reid and Mick Namararri.
These international events are not selling shows but are part of the essential culture around serious art production, keeping interest in the art alive and conferring prestige.
Events in a similar vein are occurring on Australian shores. A series of large-scale works by the late Makinti Napanangka is hanging at the Sydney Biennale, showing till mid-September. She was among the 19 Australian artists selected.
Work from the early years
Significant works by company artists, with a strong representation from the early years, feature in Desert Country, which draws on the collection of the Art Gallery of South Australia and is touring into early 2013 (it’s currently at the University of Queensland Art Museum).  The Papunya Tula artists included are Kaapa Tjampitjinpa, Long Jack Phillipus, Yala Yala Gibbs, Clifford Possum, Tim Leura, Johnny Warangkula, Mick Namararri, Turkey Tolson, George Tjungurrayi, Nyurapayia Nampitjinpa, Doreen Reid, Yinarupa Nangala and Naata Nungurrayi.
And, later this year the Art Gallery of New South Wales will hang a large selection of Papunya Tula etchings, from the entire suite that they have purchased.
Alongside these cultural events, are selling shows, including the current annual exhibition at Darwin’s Cross Cultural Art Exchange which coincides with the NATSIAAs; a smaller show at Metropolis Gallery in Geelong; the annual show with Redot Gallery in Singapore, opening on October 17; and of course the company’s annual contribution to Desert Mob here in Alice, opening on September 7. With lots of collectors in town, this is always a busy time for the gallery, as with all the serious local galleries featuring Aboriginal art.
No artist has stopped painting since the cooling of the market, says Mr Sweeney, they’ve just slowed down. The company has certainly had a conversation about its business as there’s “nothing propping this place up”. Without external support, it proudly funds its activities and more, including the establishment of a dialysis facility at Kintore, the construction of a swimming pool and, more recently, the provision of a truck-mounted mobile dialysis unit that allows its painters suffering from kidney disease to remain at home or at least to return for periods.
While things may not be what they were, there’s no cause for pessimism, says Mr Sweeney.
 

Below: One of the company’s leading artists, Patrick Tjungurrayi, at work. In 2008 he won top prize in the Western Australian Indigenous Art Awards. This year his work has been included in Forty Years of Papunya Tula Artists, Sun Valley, Idahao, USA; Visual Rhythm, Cross Cultural Art Exchange, Darwin; and the forthcoming Dreaming in Black and White at Redot Gallery, Singapore.  

 

Alice youngsters ponder becoming high fliers

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
If anyone in the audience had ambitions to become a corporate high flier they may well have changed their minds.
Bernard Salt, who addressed about 80 young people on the subject at St Philip’s College on Tuesday, sometimes gets up a 3am to write his column for the Australian newspaper, goes to work when his staff clocks on at 9am, puts in a 9 hour day and never parts from his iPhone, 24/7 and 365 days, in case a journalist wants to get a quote from him at 2am about the stock market heading north or south.
Mr Salt spends a lot of time in hotels and aeroplanes to give talks around Australia, has written four books which he says are bestsellers (“they don’t pay well but give you authority”), and is now writing another one, and he’s a partner in the professional services firm KPMG.
To achieve and maintain all this he has had to and still has to “work hard, really hard”.
Those young people from St Philip’s, OLSH and Yirara College who by this time remained fixed on becoming rich and famous got a good idea from Mr Salt about how to get there.
He told them that his rising to fame and fortune from a working-class family with six kids in the Victorian country town of Terang, where he also went to school while most of his present day acquaintances went to something like Scotch College (“you can beat them”), required unshakable self-confidence.
“Don’t be apologetic about where you come from … belief in yourself is fundamental.”
A lot of people would criticise him because they envied him but ha “always stayed the course.”
He never allowed the notion of “I can’t do this” to enter his mind from when me mapped out his life at the age of 15. He is 55.
Teachers were his early role models, he explains, until he found out what they were being paid.
Others he selected on the basis of “what can that person teach me”.
He planned his advancement three to five years ahead and put in place “markers” 10 to 15 years ahead: “I’d like to do that,” he would tell himself.
It wasn’t all plain sailing: Up to age 35 “everybody loves you” but 35 to 45 “are the toughest years … kids, relationships, work, financial pressures”.
After that the skills of building a good network kick in and the movement up the ladder of success begins in earnest, so long as you “work hard, really hard … work harder than everyone else … CEOs at the top of companies are almost possessed by working hard … it is intoxicating.”
There are jobs that are evaporating – don’t waste your time with them, he told the audience: Sales (online shopping will increase); unskilled farm work (ever bigger machines will displace humans); factory work (will go to China); tourism (will continue to decline because of the high dollar).
Get certified skills in mining, health, professional services and education.
Food, energy, water and commodities are “moving forward”.
That, in a nutshell, was the advice Mr Salt gave to the young people.
Their questions gave clues about how many may be keen to follow in Mr Salt’s footsteps.
Q: Isn’t your approach a tunnel vision, not seeing the bigger picture?
A: Blind self-belief worked for me.
Q: Are you sometimes told to relax a bit?
A: There are no half way measures at the uppermost levels.
Despite all that Mr Salt clearly has the best of both worlds: He’s been married for 33 years and has two kids, aged 25 and 22. Once a year they go overseas for a month, to a place of their choice, cost isn’t an issue, a very tangible bonus of success. However, the iPhone does go with him.
Q: Is there a glass ceiling for women?
A: Maybe in the 90s but much less so today. Don’t fall for easy cop-out: “I am a woman. I am an Aboriginal. I am working class. Remember, no cop-outs, no excuses.”
Q: Was he a good student?
A: “Not weirdly so. (General laughter.) I was in the top 5% but balanced and rounded.
Q: Are you successful?
A: Success is to meet your personal goals. You are the measure of you own success.
And that may well be being a wonderful mother, or a great social worker, as Mr Salt happily concedes.
PHOTO: Mr Salt speaking with Year 12 student, Rachel McCulloch. He was brought to Alice Springs by the Central Australian Education Foundation.

Barry Abbott will not face jury trial

By KIERAN FINNANE
 
The case against Barry Abbott (pictured), former Senior Territorian of the Year and longtime worker with young people caught up in the justice system , will now be heard by a magistrate, not by judge and jury.
A preliminary examination to see whether the case should proceed to the Supreme Court was scheduled to start today. At the penultimate moment the prosecution conceded, as the defence had pushed for all along, that it could remain in the Court of Summary Jurisdiction.
It will now be heard there from December 5 over six days. A jury trail would not have been likely before next year.
Mr Abbott was in court today together with his co-accused,  Barry Shane Abbott, Valerie Abbott, Damian McCormack and Shakira McCormack.
All are facing charges of deprivation of liberty on a number of counts (two for Mr Abbott) as well as other charges. There are also aggravated assault charges against Mr Abbott (three counts),  Mr B. S. Abbott (two counts), and Mr McCormack (one count).
The accused will enter pleas this coming Monday, following which legal argument will be heard. It concerns whether or not a particular defence is available for the 29 (of the total 35) charges of deprivation of liberty in which the victims were children. This defence relates to the circumstances in which force (providing it is not unnecessary and not likely to cause death or serious harm) is justified. One of those circumstances is in “the case of a parent or guardian of a child, or a person in the place of such parent or guardian” when force is used to “discipline, manage or control such child”.
 

Spend big on a youth centre, says councillor


UPDATE Aug 21: Comprehensive comment below by Councillor Steve Brown.
 
By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
A massive complex welcoming young people of all races, those on the edge of the law and those who are not, in the centre of the town, possibly the defunct Memo Club or on the still vacant Melanka site, is a proposal Councillor Steve Brown will be putting before the town council.
“We need to reduce the us and them thing,” he says.
“There would be no alcohol, of course, and it would be the coolest place in town.”
The project would cost $30m to $40m and require funding from the Federal and NT Governments.
Facilities would range from a milk bar to an indoor sports stadium, a venue for discos, a hostel for young people getting their first job (a function Melanka used to provide), to a hairdresser and a shop where girls can make clothes or have their nails done.
It could be a place for music band practice, martial arts classes and accessing the internet.
There could be supervised emergency accommodation for kids who have nowhere else to go at night.
“The centre would put substance into the concept of harmony and inclusion,” says Cr Brown.
“Adults have a string of clubs, but little is being done for young people outside school and sports.”
He says the current Youth Hub is unsuitable because it is too remote from the town’s centre where kids prefer to hang out.
The new centre could house some of the many youth services in town, government and NGOs, contributing an ongoing income stream for the project.
On other council business, Cr Brown says the “Port Augusta solution” will get further attention in the near future, in an internal council forum.
He says especially the current meetings where departmental heads give account of their activities need to be held once a month and they need to be under the auspices of the town council.
And the dialogue with the Aboriginal Tangentyere Council should to be enhanced: Issues such as the council rangers working together with the Tangentyere night patrol, and the tidying up of town camps, need to be looked at.
Cr Brown, who topped the vote for councillor in the election earlier this year, says a possible result, over time, could be that The Alice has just one council, not two which are structured on racial grounds.
Image: Regional youth centres are common in Australia. For example, the Coomera / Oxenford Youth Centre on the Gold Coast partners with the Northern Gold Coast Communities for Children program, the Rotary Club of Coomera Valley, Gold Coast City Council and the Nucrush Good Neighbourhood Program.  It opened its doors in November 2004 and now facilitates programs for more than 4000 people a month.

Real Action in the wrong direction?

COMMENT by RUSSELL GUY
 
The essence of the Christian faith is to see Jesus as the answer, but the Leader of the NT Opposition, Terry Mills gave a somewhat guarded response at the Australian Christian Lobby’s Make it Count forum in Darwin and relayed to Alice Springs recently.
It’s regrettable that the Chief Minister, Paul Henderson, declined to attend, because a cursory glance at political party advertising in the forthcoming NT Election reveals NT Labor favours “Moving in the Right Direction” while the Country Liberals descry “New Direction” with a caveat called “Real Action”.
Mr Mills spoke about the need for Christian voices to counter arguments so that he could have something to work with. In effect, he was calling for more citizens to involve themselves in the democratic process. This is to his credit, however, he has not responded to emails that I sent asking him about whether the CLP received campaign donations from the alcohol industry or its mates.
Questions put to him from the constituency at the ACL forum provoked a response that showed a protectionist stance towards free-market trade in land release and alcohol supply. He wants more land released for affordable housing, but implied that Aboriginal sacred sites and Native Title on Crown Land may inhibit this, justified by his statement that “everybody wants change, but not for it to happen to them.”
He is correct in identifying this as an issue, constantly reaffirming that “the ball” is in the people’s court, but ideology rears its ugly head at this juncture in a “Conservative versus the Left” contest, a spurious divide referred to by Mr Mills. It would be preferable if Mr Mills could conduct policy decisions based on evidence through the political process.
Mr Mills identified problems with this process in which he is, by vocational choice, entrapped, stating that “the public has no trust in government instrumentalities. I have a lot of work to do to build trust”. He has proposed a Planning Commission as a public interface in one policy area, but it was when a woman asked him about a floor price in relation to “grog and gunja” as serious problems in the community that Mr Mills began to reveal some of the confusion inherent in his ideology.
He failed to isolate marijuana as a substance from alcohol, but this is expected, given that he believes that “substance is not the problem, behaviour is”. This is the biggest mistake Mr Mills has made in his tilt for government and is a fundamental error which influences much of his manifesto, as alcohol-abuse does across portfolios.
He spoke about his mates’ binge drinking at the Drive-In when he was a youth, but not as if he has had direct experience of intoxication or narcosis, which is even more reason why he might avail himself of the statistical data. In formulating his alcohol policy, he appears to reject advice from police and health specialists relating to alcohol-abuse, preferring to move in his own ‘New Direction,’ penalising behaviour, but not the substance supplier, although I’m sure he’s not advocating marijuana be left on the street as he does with alcohol.
Herein lies contradiction and as the woman who asked the question concluded, he appears unconcerned with the “immature brain” or the development of the frontal cortex, which evidence states is still occurring up to people’s mid- 20’s.
His comments appeared to support NT Labor’s Alcohol and Other Drugs Tribunal while not naming it and slamming a key tool, the Banned Drinker’s Register as a failure. Both of which are linked to the rehabilitation issue. This is another expensive contradiction in an uncosted and almost totally unrevealed CLP alcohol policy.
Mr Mills continued to roll out his “it’s not the substance” line by saying that “it’s not the availability of alcohol,” followed by “why is there this destructive thirst?” He doesn’t know the answer, although he says “you’ve got to manage the substance, but you’ve got to ask the other question first.”
Sorry, Terry, but this is another contradiction. You have to manage the substance regardless and continue to ask the big question. In other words, Mr Mills cannot understand the need to “turn the tap down” and concluded the alcohol question by saying “don’t look at me to fix that, we’re all in it.”
Clearly, he is content to present a woeful understanding of alcohol management, despite evidence from around the world about the success of a floor price in reducing alcohol consumption. The NT Chief Magistrate describes alcohol as the single biggest problem the community is facing, as do the police and health officials. In light of this, NT Labor’s approach does seem to be moving generally in the right direction, while the Country Liberals are seen to be merely populist, with, at best, a simplistic and confused approach to this complex social policy.
As the Victorian Auditor General recently stated in reference to alcohol management, what’s popular doesn’t work, what’s unpopular does. That means politicians must gird themselves to manage alcohol by restricting supply, not refer to ideological blind or look for popular support.
This is the real action the community needs from its leaders. To be lost in complexity is one thing – but to subliminally design a simplistic election slogan, abetted by a “New Direction” economic growth policy, is another. It is aided by the largesse of Centrelink, some of whose programs, despite some Basics Card income management, foster alcoholism by default.
The CL stance is the essence of populist politics by a party that introduced voluntary euthanasia. Mr Mills made a big show of saying that people have “value” and should be “responsible” for their actions, but underlying this is a politician who rejects sensible evidence in favour of an ideological position.
There is a growing section of the populace who are petitioning Parliament for alcohol reform and one of the most effective can be found in the Foundation for Alcohol Research and Education (FARE) online petition to the Hon. Catherine King MP, Chair of the Australian and New Zealand Food Regulation Ministerial Council, which aims to hold the Commonwealth Government accountable for implementing a mandatory, evidence-based alcohol labelling regime in Australia, specifically, a pregnancy health warning, something which the alcohol industry has failed to do in the seven months since it was left to self-regulate.
Image: This postcard in June 2008 promoting the need of ID to buy booze is testimony to the protracted discussion of alcohol measures in the NT.

Old Timers Fete in its 45th year

Hunting for a bargain? Want to meet your mates? The Old Timers’ Fete tomorrow (Saturday) from 11am to 3pm is where it’s all at.
The fete, now in its 45th year, is run entirely by volunteers and each year raises tens of thousands of dollars for Old Timers.
Director of Nursing Mary Miles says: “Come fete day there are usually people lined up before the gates have even opened. The cake stall is
almost always sold out within the first hour.”
There will be more than 40 stalls, boxes of books for sale, tables of clothing, toys, craft, cakes, jams and preserves, face painting, food of all varieties, rides, music and more.
The fete committee, made up of Old Timers staff and resident family members, began planning four months ago for the big day.
Old Timers was the first residential aged care service established in the Northern Territory. In 1949, Rev John Flynn, the founder of the Australian Inland Mission (AIM), began the project to give “old timers” a place to rest in the shade of Mount Blatherskite.
Today, Old Timers Nursing Home provides residential care for 68 residents as well as transitional care and respite services for elderly people. Flynn Lodge provides a further 20 places and is soon to be extended to accommodate another 20 residents.
The Fred McKay Day Therapy Centre is also located at the Old Timers Village, and there are 43 self-care independent cottages on the site.
Photo: The book stall two years ago.

Keep your nose out of our business, candidate tells Amnesty International

Country Liberal candidate for Stuart Bess Price has fired a broadside at two local representatives of Amnesty International for sticking their noses into Aboriginal business and has threatened to make a formal complaint.
Amnesty also put its foot in it when Secretary General Salil Shetty visited the Utopia region in October last year.
 
Ms Price’s angry reaction follows a series of questions from James Milsom and Rachel Toovey, members of the Alice Springs Action Group of Amnesty International, to explore Ms Price’s stance on several issues, mostly about outstations in Central Australia.
 
“I have some urgent questions for you that I expect to be answered in full by August 9 (tomorrow),” Ms Price emailed them, “so that I can tell my people and all of the people of the Stuart electorate of all ethnicities what your agenda is and why they should speak up for themselves.
 
“What makes you young whitefellas from southern cities think you can speak for us?
 
“What makes you think that we can’t speak for ourselves?
 
“Who are you and how long have you been in our country?
 
“What Aboriginal languages do you speak or understand?
 
“Why do you think you can represent my views to my own people better than I can?
 
“How do we get to vote for you, when are you standing for election so that we can have our say?
 
“What is it about democracy you don’t like?
 
“How old are you and what are your qualifications that make you experts on my people’s problems,” Ms Price asked Mr Milsom and Ms Toovey.
 
Ms Price emailed: “I was born at Yuendumu. I speak Warlpiri fluently and know four other Aboriginal languages as well as English. I have worked as an interpreter/translator since I was fifteen.
 
“I am now a grandmother. My family owns all of their traditional lands through the NT Land Rights Act. My family has been involved in the development of outstations since the movement began in the 1970’s.
 
“My father tried unsuccessfully to develop an outstation at Yampirri where he was born. I supported him all that time. He died before anything was done for him. I have my own outstation at Kirrirdi which I have been trying to develop for thirty years with the support of my husband.
 
“We have not attracted any government support during that whole time. I worked for the Central Land Council for seven years. I know my people’s law, I know the country that I am kirda for through my father and kurdungurlu for through my mother.
 
“When your organisation has sent representatives here they have ignored me and my family. When Rodney Dillon came here he listened to me, told me that he heard what I had to say then reported to the government the exact opposite of what I had said. Then you sent someone calling herself a Yorta Yorta woman.
 
“She gave me two days notice of a meeting through a phone call to my husband. That was not enough time. She told him what was needed to solve the problems of my people. She had already decided without making any attempt to talk to me personally. At the time of these so called consultations I chaired the NT’s Indigenous Affairs Advisory Council.
 
“I was appointed by an Aboriginal woman minister of the NT government and served under two other NT Aboriginal woman ministers elected by the people of the Northern Territory. Your organisation sent a white blackfella from Tasmania, a wealthy man, and a woman from Victoria claiming to be indigenous who never met me or tried to talk to my people and you believed what they told you.
 
“Your organisation treated me and my people with contempt and you still do. Your organisation is undemocratic and racist. Would you send an Italian American of mixed heritage to Russia to consult with them meaningfully because he is of European descent and therefore will understand the Russians?
 
“Why do you think a physically white, English speaking Tasmanian would better understand my own people than I do? When your white supporters here in Alice Springs organise a meeting they are very careful to exclude the voices of those who disagree with them. They hand pick their Aboriginal spokespersons and then coach them on what to say. Rosie Kunoth Monks, Djiniyini Gondarra and especially Barbara Shaw do not speak for us.
 
“They have a right to their opinions and they can represent those who have given them authority to do that but they do not speak for all of us. Barbara Shaw has tried to deny my right to speak for my people on many occasions, her white supporters have publicly vilified me on the internet. You decide to promote and back the ones who think like you and ignore the rest of us.
 
“I am standing for election to the NT parliament against Karl Hampton. He is my nephew. He was elected by the people of Stuart to represent them in our parliament. I have never denied that fact. He has the right to speak for the people of Stuart because they voted for him. I think I can do a better job and I have asked the people of the electorate, which includes my family and Karl’s, to decide.
 
“Karl and I trust the people of the electorate to decide. The people you support do not represent the people of their electorates through a democratic process. But what is worse you then suppress the right of others to speak. You turn a deaf ear to those who are most vulnerable, to the most marginalised, to the women and children who are suffering so much in our communities and town camps.
 
“You take no notice of the NPY Women’s Council although they speak for the women who have sixty times the chance of dying from domestic violence than those in mainstream Australia. You go out of your way to deny their voice a hearing. So much for human rights.
 
“You and your friends make sure that there are no interpreters present at your meetings, it is always in English. You and your friends structure the meetings so that the most desperate and marginalised do not have a voice, make sure that the most aggressive and arrogant have access to the microphone and the most vulnerable and desperate don’t have a chance to speak.
 
“That is what happened when the UN’s special raconteur came to Alice. I know I was at the meeting. You are not interested in our rights you are only interested in your own agenda that you learned at the universities you attended down south.
 
“The best thing I can say about you is that you are well meaning but young, idealistic and naive, but maybe you are racist, arrogant and don’t give a damn about my people because you have your own agenda. When Aboriginal women in Central Australia ask for help, when they are killed, raped and beaten, when they cry for their abused children you ignore them and you support those who are oppressing them.
 
“When the government tries to do something for them you call them racist and you blather on about the UN. Ask the Syrians what they think of the UN. Then you send me a lecture on the homeland movement full of quotes from white researchers and lawyers with their own agendas.
 
“You treat me like a fool, like I know nothing. You are young, you are professionals, you come from rich families in Southern cities and yet you think that you can speak for my people and I don’t know what I am talking about. We now have a truly historical situation in Central Australia, we have two electorates with three Aboriginal candidates in each opposing each other. What makes you think we need you to talk to our people?”
 
Photo: Bess Price (standing) on the campaign trail.

Mandatory sentencing or not, that is the question

 
UPDATE Thursday, Aug 9, 11am
Trish van Dijk (pictured) has confirmed that her question to Adam Giles was about “mandatory sentencing per se”. It was not about the old regime that existed under the CLP when it was last in government, as suggested by Simon Walker in his comment below. She told the Alice Springs News Online this morning: “I just asked a simple question: Are you going to pursue mandatory sentencing? And the answer was ‘no’.”
 
By KIERAN FINNANE
 
Now you see it, now you don’t. The Country Liberals’ policy is to introduce minimum sentences for certain categories of assault. That’s mandatory sentencing, but according to candidates Adam Giles and Matt Conlan at yesterday’s Meet the Candidates forum in Alice Springs, mandatory sentencing is  “not happening”.
“We won’t be pursuing mandatory sentencing”, said Mr Giles to a question from Trish van Dijk at the forum.
Mr Giles went on to speak with feeling about the very high incarceration rate of Aboriginal Territorians about which he is “emotionally disturbed”. His party’s intention is to tackle the root causes of crime, including by mandatory and voluntary rehabilitation of chronic drunks, he said, but when asked whether all this meant “a definitive no” to mandatory sentencing, he again ruled it out.
Mr Conlan joined in: “It’s not happening,” he said.
Today Mr Giles ‘clarified’ his understanding of the policy for the Alice Springs News Online: “Mandatory sentencing is a catch-all for everyone on all things. We’re talking about minimum sentencing for assault on front-line service staff.”
Yet clearly, if parliament passes legislation requiring minimum sentences for certain crimes, then that is mandatory sentencing. Just last week the Country Liberals’ leader Terry Mills reiterated that the “clear choice on crime” his party is offering includes “a three-month minimum sentence for anybody convicted of an aggravated assault on workers who provide a public service”.
A minimum sentence is a mandatory sentence. It takes discretion away from judges; for the category of crime that it covers; no matter what the circumstances are, the judge must impose the  prescribed penalty on the convicted person.
Mandatory sentencing does continue under the Labor Government, most notably for murder which attracts a minimum 20 year sentence (reduced from mandatory life in 2005).
Under the last CLP Government mandatory sentencing targeted property crime. The party’s focus may have shifted to crime against the person or a certain category of person, but it clearly does still see a role for mandatory sentencing.
Apart from this, law and order issues received only minimal attention at the forum and alcohol measures, even less. The focus was much more on economic development, perhaps not surprising given that the forum had been organised by the Chamber of Commerce.
The responses from candidates of all stripes in this domain were noteworthy for their lack of a single precise proposal for infrastructure development. This was despite a focussed question, prepared by the Chamber following a business survey. It said: “Can you please advise your view on what infrastructure development is needed in Alice Springs as well as the Growth Towns as that will assist in the economic development of the region?”
Mr Giles spoke of his party’s decentralised approach, including a regional council model replacing the shires, investment in housing on outstations ($5200 per dwelling), re-engagement in Asian relations, the establishment of a Tourist Commission “owned by the industry”, and an “alignment” of the Indigenous Land Corporation, the Aboriginal Benefit Account, and Indigenous Business Australia to get better infrastructure investment in remote communities.
Ken Lechleitner, for the First Nations People’s Party (FNPP) –  he has yet to decide in which electorate to stand, Braitling or Greatorex – spoke emphatically all evening about the necessity for Aboriginal lands to be used as collateral for economic investment and development of joint ventures. This is allowed under Section 77A of the Land Rights Act, he said, which provides for traditional owners’ consent [ED: “as a group, to a particular act or thing”]. However, he did not get specific about what kind of ventures could be envisaged. On the question of tourist ventures, he said that “most of us” have never been tourists: “Give us the opportunity to have a look at what is the expectation of being a tourist and then we may be able to provide,” he said. It wasn’t clear who would be required to do the giving of the opportunity.
When discussion returned to the possible sale of Aboriginal land, Mr Lechleitner said that’s what would make for “sound business”. Labor’s Rowan Foley referred to the Section 19 leases that are available under the Land Rights Act – “normally for 20 years or less” so that consent of the Minister is not required. He also said that “technically” 99-year leases are available. [ED: 99-year leases are commercially attractive and the foundation of land tenure in the ACT, for example.]
Deborah Rock for Labor read out the record of the Henderson Government’s expenditure on infrastructure, including the aquatic centre and upgrades to schools. But, like the Country Liberals, neither she nor her colleagues had any kind of specific promise or even aspiration for the future up their sleeve.
Phil Walcott, independent for Greatorex, stressed decentralisation; Colin Furphy,  independent for Braitling, wants to see more effective marketing campaigns for tourism which will benefit the whole economy.
Barbara Shaw for the Greens (in Braitling, she has decided) spoke in general terms about the infrastructure needs “out bush” being identified by the people who live there.
No-one mentioned the Growth Towns. Despite the Chamber’s question they remain out of sight, out of mind.
During questions from the floor, Mayor Damien Ryan asked the major parties about their plans for retirement facilities in Alice Springs.
Mr Giles said the Country Liberals’ proposed Planning Commission would be looking at all infrastructure development needs and seeking to engage to private sector in the necessary investments. No commitment.
Labor’s Adam Findlay said a Labor Government will gift land to a private developer of a facility for self-funded retirees. A commitment.
The Country Liberals got an attempted drubbing from a man on the floor over the Intervention. He wanted to know what the party’s policy is, having raised it at their Sunday markets stall and having been told that it was a federal matter.
Robin Lambley tried to answer him in terms of their policy regarding child protection. He wasn’t going to have a bar of that, interrupting her more than once, refusing a “political answer” and concluding that the Liberals don’t have a policy.
Mr Lechleitner made comment about the tarring with the same brush of all Aboriginal men as child abusers, but said the Intervention has done some good in some areas.
Peter Solly of Tourism Central Australia wanted to know what the Country Liberals’ Tourism Commission would look like and what Labor would do to ensure that the industry has a greater voice.
Ms Rock replied sweetly that “as general manager of Tourism Central Australia, you are our voice” and that a Labor Government would look forward to continuing to work closely with him.
Mr Conlan said that the proposed  Tourism Commission would be a “stand-alone” body, “at arm’s length from government”, not “enslaved” to the Department of Business. He referred to the “fantastic campaigns of the ’80s and ’90s”, disrupted by the Martin Labor government in 2005. Tourism is a huge part of the NT economy and Central Australia should be it’s capital as the industry here operates 365 days a year, he said. That was as specific as it got.
Mr Foley attempted to make mileage out of recent cuts to the public service by conservative governments in the eastern states, particularly in Queensland. The CLP have foreshadowed a similar approach with their promise to cut waste, he said. We should be wary in the NT and as “we all rely on government dollars to one degree or another”, he said, and “the economy starts at home and that’s your wage packet”.
Shifting the emphasis back to making money, rather than simply receiving and spending it, Dallas Frakking on the floor wanted to know what the candidates would be doing to sort out the blockages to development on the Melanka site. Would they go to Queensland (where the site-owners are based) to help get the development off the ground?
Mrs Lambley broadened the focus in her reply, stressing the huge Territory debt ($3 billion currently), and the Top End focus of the Labor Government’s approach to economic growth, with no significant projects “south of Berrimah Line”. She returned to the issue of public service cuts, saying that only those on salaries of more than $110,000 and not in essential services would be looked at.
Ms Rock again cited a list of Labor Government investments in Alice Springs, such as the hospital upgrades and the future redevelopment of the Greatorex Building for use by police. With regard to the Melanka site, if she gets into government, she’d love to get on a plane to Queensland, she said.
The Country Liberals will also “get over there”, said Mr Giles, describing such smoothing of the creases as “the job of government”.
Photos from top: Adam Giles makes an impassioned point. To his right are fellow Country Liberals Robyn Lambley and Matt Conlan. Nearest to the camera are (from right) the Greens’ Barbara Shaw and Evelyne Roullet. The moderator, the ABC’s Rohan Barwick, is at far left. • Deborah Rock in full flight with fellow Labor candidates Adam Findlay (at right in the photo) and Rowan Foley. • First Nations’ Ken Lechleitner makes a point with feeling.• Colin Furphy (independent)  gets a laugh from Edan Baxter (First Nations, at left in the photo) and Phil Walcott (independent).
 
Related reading: Kieran Finnane’s recent interview about mandatory sentencing with president of the Criminal Lawyers Association, Russell Goldflam.

A meeting of cultures and minds

It was a meeting of cultures, peoples and minds when the Institute of Aboriginal Development launched its diary and its calendar, Jukurrpa 2013, as a tribute to Indigenous art, which features in all its splendor in the publications, under the banner “50,000 years of stories from the heart of Australia”.
Arrernte elders in the middle of the photo (from left) “MK” Turner, Angas Turner and Matthew Furber, and behind them Desart Executive Officer, Philip Watkins and IAD Press Manager, Tony Duke, were surrounded by staff from the Crowne Plaza hotel in Alice Springs.
Eseta Cowley, its Human Resources Training Operations Manager, says they are all in The Alice on special programs, from the NSW East Coast TAFEs, on Australian internships from Indonesia and the Philippines, and graduates from Deakin University, Victoria.
“All have chosen to apply for programs where they are able to experience the Outback, land, culture and people,” says Ms Cowley.
They are: Pors Chuenchai (with the sunglasses on), Samantha Harris (sunglasses on her head),  Tony Tomuli (behind and between Samantha and “MK”), Jan Vijarnpol (kneeling, holding the calendar with a painting by Naata Nungurrayi, of Irrututu, on the cover), Elvis Gumangi (kneeling next to Jan), Sandro Capri Famili (kneeling next to Elvis), Andreas Halim (standing behind Sandro), Nicola Kersley (on Andreas’ right hand) and Randy (behind Nicola).
They are frequent participants of the IAD’s Frist Friday events held to “share and celebrate achievement and opportunity for Aboriginal people in Alice Springs,” says Mr Duke.
PHOTO by Oliver Eclipse, tel 0400 181 658.

Alcohol sales in Alice dropped 12% between 2004 and 2011, but mail orders, online purchases not included

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
The total wholesale supply of all grog measured as pure alcohol has reduced in Alice Springs by 12% between 2004 and 2011, according to figures from the NT Department of Justice.
Beer went up slightly.
The figures do not include alcohol obtained by mail orders or online purchases obtained from interstate which, according to anecdotal evidence, are increasingly popular.
The most significant drop was in the supply of wine casks and fortified wines, coinciding with sales restrictions and price increases.
Casks rose four-fold from 34,000 litres (expressed in pure alcohol content) in 2004 to 135,000 in 2005 and 2006, but had dropped to 23,000 litres by 2011.
Fortified wines dropped from 174,045 litres in 2004 to just 781 litres in 2011, the major fall being in 2007.
Meanwhile bottled wine sales nearly doubled from 39,000 to 62,000 litres.
Since 2005, total wine sales have fallen from 42% to 19% of wholesale supply.
From 2010 to 2011, the total supply of pure alcohol including in cider (which doubled), wine, spirits and beer decreased by 4%, while the estimated residential population decreased by 1%.
Cider shows an increasing trend since 2004, growing at a compound annual rate of 9%.
Since 2008, cider supply has increased by 74%.
See also Letter to the Editor from Dr John Boffa, from PAAC.
Photo: Campaigners against alcohol abuse tipping out grog in Alice Springs in 2007.

The ties that bind

By KIERAN FINNANE

FROM OUR SEVEN MILLION WORD STORY ARCHIVE

It’s an election campaign like no-one else’s: parties, policies and platforms seem to matter little compared to the ties that bind.
People from across the vast electorate of Namatjira (formerly MacDonnell) were expected to converge on Papunya for the annual Sports Weekend. I made a date two weeks ago to travel out there with the community’s most famous daughter and sitting Legislative Assembly Member, Alison Anderson.
The day of travel arrives and plans change. We’ll overnight first in Hermannsburg where she must attend a funeral the next morning. My swag and stores are added to the load – her Toyota has become a rolling campaign office – and we set out.
In 2005 as a member of the Labor Party Ms Anderson won the seat with almost double the primary vote of her nearest rival, the sitting Member John Elferink (CLP). She was a Minister for the Henderson Government when she took it without contest in 2008, but something of a gulf had developed between her and the party over the Intervention. She broadly supported its measures and in The Centre nobody worked harder to translate its potential for “the little people on the ground”. For them it was, in her view, a last chance for people in remote Aboriginal communities to climb out of the cycles of poor education, welfare dependency, addictions, violence and the neglect and abuse of children. She famously resigned from the Labor Government in August 2009, in protest over the mishandling of the Strategic Indigenous Housing and Infrastructure Project (SIHIP). She sat for a year on the back benches as an independent until she joined the Country Liberals.
That will probably be the last time I mention political parties in this article for over our two-day excursion I scarcely hear a word about them, from her or anyone else. About her opponents, yes, but the focus is on what she sees as the weakness of their campaigns compared to the strength of hers. This comes down to one thing, she believes: being out there in the electorate, spending time with people in the places where they live, sitting down with them and talking with them about their lives.
Her concession to campaigning convention is in the matter of election materials, in particular corflutes. She notes with a certain pride the presence of her corflutes along our route, placed over the previous week by campaign volunteers. How much do they really matter, I want to know.
“They do matter, they remind people that there’s a contest on and what their choices are,” she says.
I watch her point them out to the people she encounters, stressing the election date – “in two weeks’ time!” She might well be confident of their support but they must remember to vote.

Visiting the sorry camp

The campaign goes on hold once we arrive at Hermannsburg. The funeral’s own strong protocols around respect for the deceased and his family are what matter. She does her part, delivering black and white funeral clothes and colourful artificial flowers to her aunty – the bereaved widow – and other relatives gathered at the sorry camp on an outstation a few kilometres from the settlement.
In the morning as the first bell rings out from the Lutheran Church, Ms Anderson joins the mourners and is soon lost in the crowd. Hundreds of people have gathered, for the dead man was an important Pitantjatjara elder, Mr Ngalkin, who had lived long decades with his Arrernte-Luritja wife, Alice. People, many of them including small children dressed in black and white, have come in from the communities all around and up from the APY lands. Many of the sympathy messages that are read out during the service come from places like Ernabella and Mutitjulu and even further afield. The inter-connections between families and language groups weave a dense web across the desert.
The church is overflowing and some mourners remain in the church yard, where the service can be heard over a PA system. Intermittently there is the wail of mourning, mixed with the voices of the Areyonga women’s choir, rising and falling like our earthly hopes. There are heartfelt readings from the gospels in Aboriginal languages and finally speeches in honour of the deceased and his family.
Grandchildren are instructed to go outside first, to form a guard of honour for the coffin. They emerge carrying wreaths and bunches of flowers. The wailing rises to a crescendo now and the bell tolls as the white coffin is carried from the church. One by one the mourners touch the coffin in farewell. A pall of sadness and distress hangs over the scene as they move towards cars to follow the hearse to the cemetery.

Time to move on

By lunchtime things seem to return to normal. People take off their black and white clothes. A long queue forms at the Top Shop takeaway and people are smiling again as they greet one another or say goodbye. Ms Anderson takes the opportunity to call in on Tjuwanpa Outstation Resource Centre, a stone’s throw from Hermannsburg, just across the Finke River. There she’s welcomed by its longtime manager Jane Rosalski.
Although the Aboriginal staff and program participants are mostly absent due the the funeral, business is booming at Tjuwanpa. The finishing touches are being put on a construction camp for New Futures Alliance workers who are due to arrive this week to start work on SIHIP housing in Hermannsburg – 26 new houses, four of them replacing dilapidated existing dwellings, Ms Rosalski understands.
Getting the contract for the camp was a second best for Tjuwanpa. They would have preferred to get the contract to build the houses, Ms Rosalski tells Ms Anderson. They could have delivered the project over five years, employing mostly a local workforce. Unfortunately there was a 12 month deadline. Ms Anderson sees it as a wasted opportunity, especially as Tjuwanpa has shown that it can deliver.
She and Ms Rosalski  take me to see the new office space (above) for Tjuwanpa’s CDEP program. This building could also function as a four-bedroom dwelling and was built by the Tjuwanpa team, including CDEP participants. The cost: $157,000. That’s well under the SIHIP average of $450,000 per unit for new houses.
Across the way is a more ambitious construction (below), nearing completion. Again it has been made largely by the Tjuwanpa team. They drew up the design based on a concept developed by the local women for what will be their training centre. On a 440sqm lot, it features four free-standing buildings grouped around an open circular courtyard covered by a roof.
Such a construction could house four related families, says Ms Rosalski , allowing them their privacy but providing an attractive central area for them to come together. Again the cost is instructive: $850,000.
“How do you get the best value for your dollar? Engage our local participants with employment and training,” she says.
She shows us over the facilities. They include a room for mothers and babies where young women will learn about caring for children, including bathing them and washing their clothes. Next door there’s a gym, which will be kitted out with exercise equipment. I’m a bit surprised by this, in a bush location where there would seem to be plenty of scope for physical activity.
But Ms Anderson says it’s important: overweight women are embarrassed to be seen walking in public, she says. Here they’ll be able to get fit on the treadmills, in privacy.
There’s also a kitchen equipped to commercial standard and it may well hold the key to the future of the whole operation.

Baking bread again 

“FaHCSIA [the federal Department of Indigenous Affairs] have been very generous with this CDEP extension funding,” explains Ms Rosalski, “but there’s no operational money. We’ve had a meeting about how we’re going to keep all this going and the women’s idea is to do a bakery. The old women remember how they used to bake bread in Hermannsburg. Now we’ll do it in Tjuwanpa.”
Another enterprise idea is to convert parts of the construction camp, once the SIHIP contract is finished, into visitors’ accommodation. It could cater for tourists – and link them with other activities offered by locals, such as art and cultural tours. It could also be a base for families visiting their relatives in Hermannsburg, as well as visiting contractors and government and NGO staff.
Ms Anderson scores a bit of a political point with some of this – on a theme close to her heart, the wastage of human and finacial resources under the SIHIP scheme – but she’s equally keen, as she says to Ms Rosalski , to “get the good news stories out there”.
“There is a some progress on communities!” she says.
The afternoon is drawing on when we set out for Papunya, stopping first on the banks of the Finke River to answer texts and take last mobile calls before we lose signal.  Heading west on dirt now, we’ve only done about 15 kilometres when we see two vehicles pulled up on the side of the road. Both of them look well worse for wear but we learn only one, a small bus, has ceased moving altogether. Ms Anderson and Leo Abbott, who is helping with her campaign, confer. Soon she is happily chatting to the women on board the bus – they’re all from Areyonga and had come in for the funeral – while Mr Abbott gets out his bag of tools and sets to work on the engine (above; below, Ms Anderson with Judy Brumby to her left, Esmeralda on her right).
Eventually, with the help of a tow – it takes two goes – the bus fires up and disappears westwards in a cloud of smoke. We don’t see them again but “our mob don’t forget thing like that,” says Mr Abbott with satisfaction. There’s a joke about votes in the bag but Ms Anderson shakes her head. For her, there’s never been any doubt of that. “Areyonga’s a great community,” she says.
Does she mean in terms of support for her or that it’s going well generally?
“Both,” she says.
We turn off the dirt onto the sealed Red Centre Way. The majestic Tnorala (Gosse’s Bluff) rises to our left. The native grasses shimmer in the late afternoon light – not much buffel out here – and we spot the occasional grass tree. “God’s country,” says Ms Anderson in response to my awe as we wind through this beautiful landscape. We stop at the Tyler’s Pass lookout and she enjoys pointing out the landmarks, one after another as we turn 360 degrees – they include Mt Zeil and Mt Sonder to the north and Haasts Bluff to the north-west, our direction.
Papunya looming
Finally we are driving straight into the setting sun, through the dust hanging in the air from the cars that have gone ahead of us. On the outskirts of Papunya, we see a tourist vehicle pulled a little way off the road, setting up camp for the night.
“It’s good, I don’t mind at all,” says Ms Anderson, “that’s what tourists want, to get out here and really enjoy the bush.”
Further on we stop while she welcomes a group from Titjikala, also getting ready to camp for the night. They include Philip Wilyuka, the new chairman of the Central Land Council, and his sister Lisa, formerly a councillor with MacDonnell Shire, now a shire employee. It’s something of a commonplace to talk of arbitrary mainstream demarcations in the desert, such as electoral and shire boundaries, but contemporary social and cultural life and the connections made possible by the car do span vast areas: here is a large group of visitors from the south-eastern corner of the Namatjira electorate, come to enjoy the biggest event on Papunya’s calendar, travelling a distance of over 350 kms.
Next morning, before the day’s games get underway, we call in on some of Ms Anderson’s family at their outstation, Three Mile. This is the home of her brother Amos and his wife Linda, a long-time teacher at Papunya School. These days their three dwellings house just six adults, as well as their little granddaughter, Imogen. But for Sports Weekend, “it’s chockers”. Most of the visitors come from Finke, again a community in the far south-eastern reaches of the electorate. The connection is made particularly through Sylvana Marks who grew up at Papunya – “our daughter”, says Ms Anderson, with a sweeping gesture that includes Linda and Amos. Sylvana has married a Doolan and now lives in Finke. Her little daughter, Zahara, is brought out to stand with Imogen for a photo. The two little girls (above right) are all dressed up for Sports’ Weekend, with Imogen in the Australian green and gold, and everyone is delighted with them.
Ms Anderson delivers pituri (native tobacco) to her mother and settles down with the women. For a while the focus is on Imogen, who has a little purse full of coins and likes to get them all out, to “count” them with her grandfather. Later this kitty will come in handy, providing the cash float for Sid Anderson’s barbecue stall at the oval, the coins replaced with notes (I didn’t get to see Imogen’s face when she next inspected her purse!).
Getting going in the morning
With the sun already high in the sky, Ms Anderson’s niece Makisha gets ready for softball umpire duties. Her mother Linda comments that back in her day, three games would have already been played: “I had to get up early!”
We arrive at the oval around lunchtime. The first game of footy is about to start, Utopia versus the Kintore Hawks. Utopia want me to take their photo (see at the end of the article). One of the team, on his own initiative, organises them to turn to face the sun, so that I’ll get good exposure on their faces. The pride is clear, the mood upbeat.

Utopia versus the Kintore Hawks. Utopia won. 

The match gets underway and little by little the cars and spectators start arriving. Ms Anderson greets almost everyone in her path. Here are visitors from Napperby. They tell her they were pulled up by police on the way in. There’s a slight air of complaint but Ms Anderson won’t have it: “That’s their job,” she says, “they’ve gotta do it. They pull me up too.”
A little while later police themselves drive up. They’ve come in from Kintore to help out the Papunya police on their big weekend. They stop for a long chat with Ms Anderson. The senior officer tells her: “I love it there, you’ll need a crowbar to get me out, the people are good, the population’s growing.” He talks about problems too in a useful exchange of information.
Meanwhile Sid Anderson (MacDonnell Shire President and Ms Anderson’s older brother) arrives with supplies for a food stall – meat, bread, onions and soft drink. Leo Abbott offers to do the cooking and soon the tempting smell of barbecued meat and fried onions draws the first customers. A soft-serve icecream van does the rounds and Imogen scores a treat.
Ms Anderson makes her way from car to car, group to group. She urges the Haasts Bluff football team to don their colours for a photo (see at the end of the article), and sits down with some of the Haasts Bluff women (Doreen Lane in shadow, Hazel Butler in front, Vronita Malta in pink sweater, then Verna Abbott) while they get ready. Most of these exchanges happen in Aboriginal languages, of course, though there’s frequently a peppering of English, especially for things to do with the mainstream world.
Does she talk to people about issues, about what she and her party can do for them?
Yes, of course: “I tell them we support homelands as long as kids are going to school. They may live in communities but they all have families who live on homelands [outstations]. There are three outstations around Haasts Bluff, for example.”
She dismisses the NT Government’s recent announcement of additional funding for homelands, and argues for per capita funding, citing the example of Bonya, a tiny community in the north-eastern Sandover-Plenty region of the electorate, which looks after five outstations.  There the population is growing, she says, but the funding isn’t. Overcrowding is an issue with 50 to 60 people sharing eight dwellings.
(Per capita funding would appear to go further than her party’s policy which, like the NT Government’s, is focussed on maintaining existing housing stock that is permanently occupied. The government is committing “up to $20,000” per dwelling, while the CLP’s policy is to allocate $5200 per dwelling.)
The dirt and the ‘whoops’
During the drive out the conditions of roads in the electorate is a point of discussion. The dirt and gravel roads we take are on the whole in good condition, although on the way back there are sections of ‘whoops’ on the Gary Junction Road that would rival the Finke Desert Race track. If you take these side on, you roll.
We take them front on and go bouncing along, fine in the Toyota, much more testing for the old two-wheel drives owned by many community people. But this is definitely not the worst road in the electorate. It doesn’t rate in Ms Anderson’s list of the ones that need urgent attention: the Ernest Giles Road into Kings Canyon – “absolutely terrible!” – and the roads to Titjikala, Docker River and Santa Teresa.
The government’s ears must be burning, for virtually as we talk they announce money (an unspecified amount) for upgrading gravel sections of the road to Santa Teresa (the only road in The Centre to benefit from the total package announced).
Other issues come up in conversation as we move around. Housing’s a big topic. Ms Anderson makes a point about the necessity to think ahead and cater in each house for people’s possible future disabilities: “If it’s not done out bush, then sooner or later people will end up in town.”
More jobs for young people is another issue for people throughout the electorate, she says. Why then, I ask, don’t they take jobs at Hermannsburg’s Finke River Mission store, for example? When we stop there to buy the makings for sandwiches, there are only white staff on the cash registers. That’s because of the funeral, normally Aboriginal staff do work there, including on the cash registers, she assures me.
Her brother Amos tells me that his eldest daughter, Natasha, has come home for Sports Weekend from Adelaide where she works as an interpreter. She completed high school in Alice Springs, boarding with her Aunty Alison. How does he feel about her living so far away now?
Making their own lives 
“It’s good,” says Mr Anderson. “When they grow up, they should be independent. They’ve been to school, they’ve got opportunities to make their own life.”
His son, who went to St John’s in Darwin for his secondary education, is working for the Central Land Council’s ranger program.
Dissatisfaction with the shires is another issue, says Ms Anderson: “People feel the shires have taken away their voice.”
If they’re financially unsustainable now, I suggest, how much more so will that be the case if they’re broken up into smaller councils, losing the advantage of economies of scale. She challenges that. Maintaining centralised control in a town-based HQ is expensive in itself. For instance, there are managers of shire services based on all the main communities and “then there’s a bloke who goes around checking up on them all”. That’s an example of money (his wages and associated costs) that could be saved with smaller-scale organisations. She suggests some logical clusterings, of people and communities strongly connected by family ties and language. For example: Kintore, Mt Liebig, Papunya and Haasts Bluff; Docker River, Mutitjulu, Areyonga, Imanpa; Finke, Titjikala, Santa Teresa and Amoonguna.
But it will be up to them, she stresses.
These conversations, about issues and policy, are short-lived. The energy out here is about the more intimate matters of people’s lives: a young mother’s hopes of having her baby returned to her now that there’s some family support in place; the obvious need for a change in diet for an obese boy; the many early deaths that families, including her own, suffer.  “Poor thing” is a phrase often on her lips. But there’s also a lot of joking, teasing and laughter, a great pleasure taken in the company of others, that pushes into the background the signs of poverty, ill health and inertia that are so striking for an outsider.

Below: Haasts Bluff football team; bottom: Utopia football team.  

 

PHOTO at top:  With family at Three Mile outstation, Papunya: Alison Anderson in the pink top; to her left Sylvana Marks, to her right Makisha Anderson, nieces. Makisha’s mother Linda in the striped top; Alison’s mother Beverley, front ; Linda’s eldest daughter Natasha in green.

What a week!

COMMENT by ERWIN CHLANDA
 
When you go to the election forum to be hosted by the Chamber of Commerce on Tuesday (6pm, CDU), will you …
[A] As was the case in the Greatorex forum last week, put up with a jolly chat between the candidates and group hugs for the cameras; with pronouncements such as “I’m relaxed about having some sort of regional body in place;” or being “very guided” the constituents; with rambling about issues ranging from railway crossings to teaching Aborigines how to live in a house, in the total absence of any precise and costed policy or strategy to deal with any of the issues? Or …
[B] Will you articulate what you think the town needs; demand clear and firm undertakings from the candidates, should they be elected and from the government, that they will fight for the implementation of what they promise, and that they will resign as Members of Parliament if their government reneges on these election promises?
Isn’t anything less just a waste of time?
• • •
Independents elected can quite easily play this tough game as well, given the predicted close outcome: But results will depend on how resolute they are if a deal is broken. Their Federal counterparts are not good role models.
• • •
The forum host itself may do a little explaining why the chamber, one of the key lobbies of this town, persistently avoids the issue of exorbitant fuel prices – as are the town council and Tourism Central Australia.
• • •
Our report “Will Alice become a fly-in, fly-out town?” contains a string of issues the post August 25 government must tackle. Hands up all those who think The Alice is still a great place to raise a family? What will you ask the pollies to do?
• • •
Good on the cops for investigating, arresting, charging and now also shaming drug dealers. Green signs saying “Warning – these premises drug premises” are now on three local houses.
• • •
It would be a most useful exercise for the Opposition to publish public funding calculations based in the size of the populations in The Centre and the Top End, respectively. This would need to include NT, Federal and joint allocations. Example: Road funding announced last week is shamefully Top End heavy. I wonder what the Labor candidates will have to say about this on Tuesday.

Alice houses marked as illicit drug premises

Three houses believed to be involved in the supply of drugs are now the subject of Drug Premises Orders following their identification during the recently completed Operation Caesar in Alice Springs.
Superintendent Brent Warren says police arrested several people and seized thousands of dollars worth of cash relating to drug offences in the town.
The application for Drug Premises Orders was part of an ongoing strategy by the Southern Substance Abuse Intelligence Desk (SAID) to target the supply of illicit substances from Alice Springs residences into remote communities.
“The SAID is a Department of Families, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs funded initiative and works to gather intelligence on suppliers and criminal network and works closely with the Dog Operations Unit (DOU) to investigate drug dealing and substance abuse in the cross border region,” said Superintendent Warren.
“Three residences in Alice Springs now display Declared Drug Premises signs which give police broad powers to enter, search and seize evidence at these locations.
“The posting of these signs is yet another weapon in the armory for police against the scourge of drug dealing and should serve as a warning to offenders that police continue to treat these matters very seriously.
“Anybody with information about drug dealing is encouraged to ring Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or contact the local police station.  Information can be provided anonymously.”

Pictured: A Declared Drug Premises sign on the fence of a house in Palmer’s Camp, a town lease area Basso Road.

Booze and parties: August 25 crunch time

COMMENT by RUSSELL GUY
 
With the death of Kwementyaye Briscoe in the Alice Springs police watchhouse in January (the image at right was produced in evidence at the inquest), and the recent death of Thomas Kelly in Kings Cross, there is a rapidly increasing public awareness of the fact that Australians have allowed a national drinking culture to escalate into unacceptable levels of alcohol-related violence and self-harm.
This week, the Australian Drug Foundation (ADF) said: “There has been an explosion in the supply of cheap alcohol, which has made ‘loading-up’ at home before heading out to clubs and bars acceptable.”
In WA, the McCuster Centre For Action on Alcohol and Youth (MCAAY) has just released several reports on the alcohol industry and its effect on young people.
A new report on alcohol product labeling was released today by the Foundation for Alcohol Research and Education (FARE) as it increases pressure on governments to enforce the abysmal failure of the alcohol industry to self-regulate.  Meanwhile, a plan to introduce liquor restrictions across the Pilbara has raised the ire of local businesses, supermarket chains and powerful industry groups.
Last year, I was surprised to read in the NT News that the alcohol industry contributes to the political campaign funds of the two parties contesting the forthcoming NT election. I asked the leaders of these parties if this was correct, but to date, I have received no reply.
Campaign donation figures available to the public are often from companies or donors whose connections to the liquor industry are not clear, but neither Opposition Leader Terry Mills nor Chief Minister Paul Henderson will provide explanations.
The MCAAY says the UK based, Altria Group has revenues of US$28,311million p.a.
One of its key brands is VB, the “green cans” often the choice of problem drinkers, which proclaims its sporting sponsorship as “Proudly supporting Cricket Australia, Surfing Australia and NRL.”
As further evidence for the expanding alcohol industry, I was also surprised to learn of the recent agreement between Coca-Cola and the alcohol industry, as distributors for Jim Beam, other bourbons and Galliano.
The list of major liquor merchants headquartered in Australia is also extensive, including Wesfarmers (owner of Coles and 93 hotels), Woolworths (with 37% of liquor retailing market share) and Metcash, Australia’s leading wholesale distributor, supplying over 15,000 hotels, liquor stores and restaurants, including online outlets.
Liquorland, Cellarbrations and 450 Thirsty Camels are included in outlets controlled by these three Australian suppliers.  Woolworths (1250 stores), Coles (785 stores) and IGA compete for the burgeoning alcohol dollar.
Take-away is where the money is (70% of alcohol sold in the NT is take-away). Agitating for take-away sales-free days is asking for a trade-off in lives over profit. Unsurprisingly, restricting this supply is not a popular call.
However, research-based organizations, including the National Alliance for Action on Alcohol (NAAA) are networking with nationally placed, community-based organizations like Alice Springs’ People’s Alcohol Action Coalition (PAAC) and many others, to expose the activities of the alcohol industry and their vested interests.
In relation to young people, the MCAAY says: “The brain is still developing until the early 20s and is more sensitive to the effect of alcohol on structural and functional development as the prefrontal cortex is still developing.”
But in formulating the NT Country Liberals’ alcohol policy, Terry Mills, the Leader of the NT Opposition makes the prima facie claim “It’s behavior that’s the problem, not the substance.”
According to MCAAY, over the last 10 years about 15% of all deaths among 15-24 year olds were due to risky / high risk drinking.  On average, five Australians under 25 die from injury or disease caused by hazardous drinking each week and Indigenous people are more than twice as likely to die.
Why is that?  Evidence produced by MCAAY is captured in the quotes “Drinking is the best way of relaxing” and “One of the main reasons I drink is to get drunk” (50.1% and 43.3% of 16-17 year old WA school students respectively), a figure which shows a significant increase.  Up to 70% of police responses are alcohol-related and increasing, as are annual budgets for alcohol-abuse.
The alcohol industry is multi-tentacled, stretching across continents, allegedly into the campaigns of the NT political parties, supermarkets, service stations and expanding, but when an intoxicated Indigenous woman holds up her hand and stops a train besides the now ironically named, Little Sisters Town Camp, it could be that she’s saying “Stop!” to the free market grog trade decimating her community.
The tragedy is that it doesn’t stop there.  If this woman is pregnant, the unborn child is likely to suffer Foetal Alcohol Sprectrum Disorder.
Terry Mills faces the Australian Christian Lobby’s Make it Count Election Forum at CDU, Darwin next Thursday, August 9 at 7:30pm. The webcast will be streamed live to the Baptist Church, cnr Crispe and Brown St, Alice Springs.
Paul Henderson, NT Chief Minister declined to participate.
Photo above: No, it isn’t. The new 30 can VB pack declares itself “Proudly Australian” when it’s owned by UK-based Altria Group, parent company of US tobacco giant Philip Morris.’

Centre poor cousin in road funding

Central Australia is getting merely crumbs off the table in “a significant investment in bush roads across the Territory” by the Federal and NT Governments.
Malarndirri McCarthy, NT Minister for Regional Development, and Warren Snowdon, Member for Lingiari, announced today they would be committing $16m and $90m, respectively, to a “new Regional Roads Productivity Package” to “encourage growth and development in a number of communities and local industries”.
The slice of that for Central Australia will be for “upgrading the gravel condition of priority sections” – no lengths or costs disclosed – of the Santa Teresa Way whose total length is about 70 kms.
All other “identified projects” are in the Top End:
• Roper Highway, causeways and associated works, targeted strengthening and widening;
• Port Keats Road, targeted sealing and flood immunity improvements;
• Central Arnhem Road, construction of a new bridge over Rocky Bottom Creek;
• Buntine Highway, targeted strengthening, widening and sealing works; and
• Arnhem Link Road, upgrading the gravel condition of priority sections;
The Northern Territory Government will fully scope the projects to determine which sections of these roads to prioritise and what work needs to be done, the media release says.
“These regional roads are major arteries connecting and providing access to communities, supporting tourism, the cattle and resources sector as well as improving the economic opportunities for Territorians living in remote areas,” Ms McCarthy is quoted.
“Along with our investment into our Territory Growth Towns this is about growing our regional economies and creating more jobs in the bush.”
Mr Snowdon is quoted as saying: “The investment in regional roads is a win not only for unlocking economic opportunities but also for improving access to essential services.
“This new funding is in addition to the unprecedented $635.6 million the Federal Labor Government is providing under the current six-year Nation Building Program (2008-09 to 2013-14) to rebuild and renew the Territory’s road infrastructure.”

Will Alice become a fly-in, fly-out town? Only 71 new family type homes in 5 years

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
Is Alice Springs becoming a fly-in, fly-out centre? Statistics say it looks like it.
A growing number of people working or spending time here do not call Alice home. 
Only 71 “family type” three bedroom homes were built between 2006 and 2011, whereas a much greater number of flats, units and apartments were constructed.
However the FIFO workers aren’t engaged in the lucrative mining industry, but most likely in the public service, in government initiatives such as the NT Emergency Response and Closing The Gap, says Dr Andrew Taylor, Senior Research Fellow, Demography and Growth Planning, of the Northern Institute, commenting on the five year Australian census results just released.
He says the biggest “industry” in Alice Springs is government administration. The proportion of employment in that sector “has been growing steadily over the past 10 years or so”.
Yet the town’s resident population has grown only marginally in the last five years, by 5.5% and in fact the current official figure of 28,500 is down 100 on the year before, 2010.
“All of the growth from 2006 to 2011 took place in 2006 and 2007, and since 2008 there has been a slight decrease,” says Dr Taylor.
 This takes in both Indigenous and non-Indigenous people.
It’s clear “we struggle to retain people on a long term basis. Teachers are a classic example”.
This is going to be more of a problem as a “big cohort” of public servants is approaching retirement.
Nevertheless, the population 55 and over has increased by about 20%.
“That growth took place in 2006 and 2007, and since 2008 there has been a slight decrease,” says Dr Taylor.
 This takes in both Indigenous and non-Indigenous people.
 It may be the case that more people are staying here after retirement – and perhaps  fewer “cashing in their house and leaving the Territory,” he says, but the increase is from a low base.
“Getting several generations of one family to remain in town is the ultimate aim.”
There also was a large growth in the non-indigenous population, in their early career ages, who are calling Alice home.
 That group has increased by about 13% (20 to 24 by 6%; 25 to 29 by 20% and 30 to 34 by 14%).
There is nothing in the Census data to support the often raised specter of urban drift from Aboriginal communities: on the contrary, the number of Indigenous people aged 20-34 who call the town home has fallen by 9%.
Dr Taylor says: “Ascertaining who is in town, when and for what reason is difficult.”
Reasons that others have put forward for people being in town temporarily include visiting family, opportunities of living in town, trouble in other communities, alcohol regulations in town and out bush, plus other factors.
Even thought the 20-34 years age group declined, overall the town’s Aboriginal population grew by 5% over five years – 1% a year – while the non indigenous growth rate was 5.5% over the five years
Both growth rates are very low, by national standards.
Dr Taylor says it’s very hard to determine how many of these are moving to and from bush communities but not working here: the employment statistics are not due out until later in the year. However, that Alice is on the way to become a black town is no more than an urban myth, on the present figures.
The town camp population is lower than in in 2006.
A major development is the influx of people from NZ, India and the Philippines. Overseas born residents  now make up 20% of the population – the same percentage as the Aboriginal population.
It’s more likely that Aboriginal migration, following global population trends, will be mostly to the big cities, Darwin and interstate, in our case, says Dr Taylor.
A clearer picture about the Aboriginal employment participation rate will emerge in the job stats later this year, but Dr Taylor says the “general consensus” is that participation rates for Indigenous Territorians are around  half of the non-indigenous rate of 80%, and this changed little during the last 10 years.
By and large, recruiting staff in the NT is inefficient, largely because we don’t have the “core” of workers which the states enjoy: If Victoria needs a teacher in Geelong they will get one from Melbourne.
 If Alice or Yuendumu needs a teacher, he or she is likely to come from Brisbane or Adelaide.
The census shows a 6% decline in the 15 to 19 non-indigenous age group indicating we may be failing to retain our kids to study in the NT.
 Dr Taylor says the global trend towards off-campus courses, using digital technology, could help reverse that trend.
The figures in the tourism industry are bleak.
 In the 12 years between 1999 and 2011 holiday makers declined by around 40%.
 The corporate and convention business may be more stable while the backpack market may have fallen a staggering 50%.
Dr Taylor says we are failing to take account of “changed desires” of tourists. 
We’re still focussed on our icons but visitors are looking for something more substantial than a snap of The Rock.
 They want something they can take away with them, a skill, a scuba ticket, for example, or an adventure like mustering and branding work on a cattle station.
As operators offer this in the more easily accessible parts of the country, people don’t bother spending the money on going all the way to The Centre.
Dr Taylor says the 4WD and grey nomad markets seem to be holding up but they are highly networked groups, always on the look-out for advantages and opportunities – or reasons for not going to some place.
 Dr Taylor says “pockets of success” in the sector include the Flinders Ranges in SA – a long way from our neck of the woods.
He will be one of the four guest speakers at next week’s public symposium on Future Directions in Alice Springs at CDU.
Photo: On present trends, when kids pictured above in the 2010 Bangtail Muster reach their teens, their town won’t be much bigger, the racial composition will be much the same, they will head interstate to do their tertiary education, the population will be older and a booming tourism industry in The Centre will be the fond memory recalled in a Skype chat with their grandparents.

Revitalisation works just about set to go

Parsons Street East, 3D rendering. Courtesy ASTC, CAT Projects, and Susan Dugdale & Associates. 

 
By KIERAN FINNANE
 
The architectural design for the redevelopment of the northern end of Todd Mall and Parsons Street is all but complete. The key visual features of the design are the moth-like shade structures, which will be placed in a number of clusters along the eastern side of the mall and the southern side of Parsons Street.
Their central poles will be used to support much of the street furniture that at present clutters the street-scape. This includes CCTV cameras, bike racks, rubbish bins and lighting. Some of the moth wings will also become the canvas for public art work, the brief for which is also nearing completion.
Seating beneath the moths will be in the form of brick benches, using bricks from the rotunda which will be dismantled, with particular attention to the ‘founder bricks’ bearing the names of local families and individuals.
Underground services have now been identified, the plan for engineering works is finished and being reviewed, and the lighting and electrical design is well progressed.
This update was provided to the Alice Springs Town Council on Monday by Lyndon Frearson, general manager of CAT Projects, who are project managing the revitalisation works.
The traffic management report is completed, with a peak of 2500 vehicle movements per day being planned for.
While works are underway the vacant site of the old Mobil Palms petrol station will be used as a temporary carpark. Whether it remains a carpark afterwards will be up to the owners, said Mr Frearson.
The owners of the ANZ carpark (Yeperenye Pty Ltd) have agreed to a redesign, with a new entrance to the carpark from Leichardt Terrace.
The CCTV camera design is underway, and regulatory approvals are in place with the exception of the Aboriginal Areas Protection Authority (AAPA) approvals. Mr Frearson said all works are consistent with the discussions held with AAPA and he did not expect any delays.
The horticulture brief is “60% complete”.
As has been widely canvassed, the northern end of the mall will be opened to two-way traffic turning east into Parsons Street. Light traffic will be able to travel in both directions, said Mr Frearson, but heavy vehicles will only be able to go one way, entering Parsons Street from Leichardt Terrace and travelling northwards up the mall to Wills Terrace. Red bitumen will be used for the road surface.
Where the rotunda and sails are now will become a “shared zone” for both pedestrians and vehicles (design pictured above). Different coloured and textured surfaces will signal the transitions and crash bollards will mark the edges, providing a safety barrier for pedestrians. The bollards will be able to be moved to change the configuration of the space, for instance on market days, closing off certain areas to traffic.
A space has been created in front of the “grandfather tree” (on the western side of Parsons Street) for a temporary stage. A performance area in the vicinity of Adelaide House is part of the concept for the later stages of the revitalisation project, but these stages are unfunded and their future uncertain.
Work is expected to begin in the last week of September and Parsons Street will be usable in time for the Christmas markets.

Greatorex forum: where was the fourth candidate? And where were the voters?

By KIERAN FINNANE
 
It was a “job interview” and he didn’t turn up. First question to the other three contenders for the Legislative Assembly seat of Greatorex was, “Where’s the CLP candidate? Has there been any apology from him?”
This was the ‘meet the candidate’ forum for Greatorex, organised well in advance by independent candidate Phil Walcott to which all contenders were invited.
“If someone chooses to not turn up for the interview, well …,” said Mr Walcott, explaining that incumbent Matt Conlan (Country Liberals) had indicated that he would not attend via a letter to the editor in the Centralian Advocate last week.
Joining Mr Walcott to outline their platform and answer questions were the ALP candidate Rowan Foley and the Greens’ recently announced contender, Evelyne Roullet.
It seems though that the campaign is hardly setting the electorate on fire. A dozen constituents turned up. Local media from three outlets were also in attendance.
Alcohol policies were an inevitable focus.
Mr Foley pointed to yesterday’s press release from Alcohol Policy Minister Delia Lawrie, claiming a “6% drop in crime” linked to the Banned Drinkers’ Register (BDR).
He didn’t mention that this figure excludes alcohol-related assaults associated with domestic violence.
The full report, also released yesterday, reveals that alcohol-related assaults associated with DV increased by 7.8% across the NT. However, it says this increase “is a reflection of the initiatives implemented by Police to encourage the reporting of DV and the improvement in the procedure of recording DV related assaults”.
The figures for Alice Springs in both categories show a decline, down 1.7% and 2.1% respectively. Darwin, Katherine and Palmerston similarly show declines. The Territory total is pushed up by increases in Tennant Creek, Nhulunbuy and “NT – balance”.
Ms Lawrie also pointed to fewer – by a “staggering” 10,000 – anti-social behavior incidents. While emphasising the BDR, she also outlined the government’s other measures, including the SMART court,  the Alcohol and other Drugs Tribunal, and reduction in “the pathways to treatment”, from eight days to three hours.
Mr Walcott dismissed the ID-based BDR, saying that it doesn’t work and that drinkers will always find a way around it, but he criticised the CLP’s approach as more interested in punishment that in solving the issue. He pushed for an agreed approach, not based on “us and them”.
Ms Roullet, who in her own words speaks with “a very strong French accent” but has nonetheless lived in Alice since the 1970s, acknowledges the problem, but sees it as a symptom. The underlying causes are what need to be addressed, in collaboration with Aboriginal people themselves.
The candidates were quizzed on town planning and what they thought about having “greater control” based in Alice Springs.
A central point of Mr Walcott’s campaign is to regionalise, not centralise. “Stuff that belongs in Central Australia” should be dealt with by people here, he said.
Ms Roullet agreed, while Mr Foley said he was “relaxed about having some sort of regional body in place”.
Ms Roullet stressed the need for affordable accommodation, harking back to her early experience in Alice Springs when people were able to pay a $500 deposit on a home and pay it off over 45 years.
The issue of the railway crossing at the main intersection of Larapinta Drive and Stott Terrace was raised. On this point the moderator Kay Eade, present as a resident of Greatorex (not in her Chamber of Commerce role), had more to say than the candidates. She warned of “a lost opportunity” in not negotiating with mining and exploration companies for investment in a solution, such as a rail by-pass. She stressed the problem of the western side of town being cut off from emergency services while the level crossing is closed, and said that wait times will only increase with the expansion of Roxby Downs. She suggested that all three tiers of government combine to negotiate a funded solution with mining companies.
A possible uranium mine at Angela-Pamela got the thumbs down from all candidates (the issue is central to Mr Foley’s campaign).
Mr Walcott was asked what he would do in the event of a hung parliament. Would he negotiate a deal with whoever was in government, as Gerry Woods has done. Mr Walcott said he couldn’t commit himself on the issue until he sees the composition of the parliament, where it is possible that there would be four independents. He would be “very guided” by his constituents.
Mr Foley had earlier raised “the tragedy” at White Gate – the so-called “informal” town camp on the eastern fringes of town, home to a number of native title holder families, with very limited infrastructure. He said “we need to focus our resources” on doing something about it. The Alice Springs News Online asked him what specifically and whether he had raised the issue with government. “Not yet,” he said.
Ms Eade raised another issue  – tenant behaviour in public housing. “Not their fault”, she said when they have not been educated to live in housing. It’s an issue close to home, literally, as her neighbours come from an outlying small community. The tenant is a grandmother whom she gets on well with but when this woman is away and family are visiting there are significant problems, including noise. She says complaints “fall on deaf ears”.
Mr Walcott said there are “lots of mentoring opportunities” in such situations and Ms Roullet said we need people – “social workers” – to teach Aboriginal people how to live in houses.
After the forum the Alice News asked about preference allocation. Mr Walcott said he would not be preferencing anyone, in line with his independent stance.  Mr Foley said that the final decision will not be up to him, but rather Labor’s campaign director for the whole of the NT.
Photo (from left): Rowan Foley, Evelyne Roullet and Phil Walcott – but where is Matt?

Tourist complains about LPG Autogas price: town lobbies don't seem to give a hoot

UPDATE Saturday Aug 4 at 09:40am
The Alice Springs News Online has received information from a fuel retailer which seems to contradict assertions that it are the service stations which are “ripping off” the public.
The retailer, who spoke to us on the condition of not being named, this week bought diesel for about $1.50 a liter (he gave us the exact figure). To calculate his retail price he needs to deduct the GST, add his 8 cent mark-up and apply GST to that price which finishes up around $1.58. Despite sharp drops in the benchmark price of fuel, the bowser price in Alice Springs has not decreased significantly. As the mark-up applied by our source is reasonable by national standards, this raises the question whether others in the supply chain are over-charging.
So far the industry has been stonewalling inquiries from the  Alice Springs News Online.
 
UPDATE Friday Aug 3 at 11:30am
Alice Springs fuel retailers are continuing to line their pockets with record margins, showing no concerns for the public by failing to pass on available savings.
This is the view of Edon Bell, the General Manager of the Automobile Association of the NT which has more than 20,000 members.
He says the benchmark price for LPG Autogas has dropped from 61c on April 1 to about 33c at the beginning of this month.
To charge 109.9c a liter this week is “once again ripping off the public,” he says.
“Fuel is not a luxury item in the NT. It’s something everybody has to buy. We have no choice.
“But nobody puts any pressure on the retailers who clearly have only their own interests in mind.”
 
COMMENT by ERWIN CHLANDA
POSTED Thursday Aug 2 at 11:46am
Are our high and mighty aware of the NT election in three weeks’ time?
It doesn’t appear so. Let’s take it from the top.
Alice Springs tourist industry has slumped 40% (holiday makers) and 50% (backpackers) in the past 10 years.
One sector still buoyant and prospective are the 4WD enthusiasts and the grey nomads, many of whom have dual-fuel vehicles, namely gas and petrol.
On July 24 visitor Jason Trevers, from Adelaide, wrote to the Alice Springs News Online, aghast that LPG Autogas in Alice should cost twice as much as in Adelaide. You heard right: double the price. 100% more.
He responded in the comment box below our report of June 27 which was about the owners of service stations in Alice Springs who do not pass on savings to their clients when the price of petrol goes down.
We emailed last Thursday the three valiant defenders of our town, the knights in shining armor, the Alice’s principal lobbies, those who can make governments shake in their boots, namely the Town Council (via Mayor Damien Ryan), the Chamber of Commerce and Tourism Central Australia.
We asked them: What will you do about this?
By Monday we had heard nothing from any of them, so we emailed a reminder.
Today is Thursday and we have still have had no response to our question.
It seems a complaint from a visitor to our town, Mr Trevers, is of no importance to these organisations.
We did a spot check in Adelaide:  A Liberty servo in Pooraka and a BP one in Plympton sell LPG Autogas for 55.9 cents a liter.
The Caltex service station on the North Stuart Highway on Tuesday charged 109.9 cents (photo).
We have asked the servo’s manager to comment. We will report his comments if and when we get it.
None of the Alice Springs servos’ owners had responded to our invitation to comment about our June 27 article.
Our tourism industry is hanging by a thread, which is principally the self drive market.
These people have an excellent network, via UHF, email, websites and face to face, are constantly on the lookout for opportunities – as well as reasons not to go to places that treat them with contempt.
Over to you, leaders of the town.

Council asked to consider spectre of transport accident involving radioactive waste

The NT Fire and Rescue Service in their HAZMAT suits. Their role is to ‘identify, isolate and contain’. Photo courtesy NTFRS. 

 
By KIERAN FINNANE
 
The Alice Springs Town Council was challenged at last night’s meeting to take action regarding the proposed radioactive waste dump at Muckaty, Aboriginal land 120 kms north of Tennant Creek.
The key issue put to councillors was that local emergency services do not have the capacity to respond to an accident involving radioactive waste material on Alice’s road or rail networks.
This was argued by a deputation from the NT branch of United Voice (a workers union), the Public Health Association and the Beyond Nuclear Initiative.
The Alice Springs News Online asked the NT Fire and Rescue Service to comment on this proposition. We received this statement in reply:
“The Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Division is responsible for management of radioactive waste.
“However if, for example, a transport incident occurred involving radioactive waste on a Territory road or railway, a multi agency response would be activated in accordance with existing Emergency Response plans to identify the material, isolate and contain until such time as the lead agency takes over management.
“The NT Fire and Rescue Service has equipment and training to undertake their duties of ‘identify, isolate and contain’.”
The deputation want council to support their call for an independent enquiry into long-term nuclear waste storage, “to get it right from the beginning”. The current proposal to store waste at Muckaty does not, they say, achieve world best practice nor is it based on scientific principle.
The key point regarding best practice is that the proposal will see long-lasting intermediate level waste being stored above ground while international best practice requires it to be stored underground. The above ground storage is an interim solution, they say, pending the establishment of a “deep underground geological disposal facility”.
As the government has made no progress on this to date, they argue that “‘interim’ storage in the NT is set to last many hundreds of years”. How ‘”to date” runs to “many hundreds of years” was not explained.
The failure of the proposal as they see it with respect to “scientific principle” is that Muckaty was not on the short-list as a “suitable” site when a national repository site selection study was undertaken in the 1990s.
It has become the only site under current consideration because it was nominated by the Northern Land Council, supposedly on behalf of traditional owners (one family group within the Ngapa clan).
The legal basis of this nomination is being challenged in the Federal Court on behalf of dissenting groups of the Ngapa clan. The Federal Minister for Resources and Energy Martin Ferguson is on the record (Australian Financial Review, March 14, 2012) as saying the government will respect the decision of the court.
If the court rules that the nomination is illegal, then it will be back to square one as Mr Ferguson is also on the record that a site can be considered only if it has been volunteered, an important difference, he says, between the laws of his government and the Howard government.
Arguably, however, the consent of one small group of traditional owners would not dispose of the issue, as the waste would have to travel across vast distances in Australia to reach the site and there can never be a risk-free transport route (the deputation point to recent incidents involving hazardous material, such as the derailment at Edith River in December last year). As world best practice for radioactive waste disposal also requires “informed consent”, they say, they are approaching local councils along the possible transport routes, to elicit their support for the independent enquiry.
The group argues that the waste from nuclear medicine should continue to be stored locally at the hospitals where it is used. The radioactivity of most of it is very short-term and breaks down very quickly, after which the waste is disposed of in local landfills. The small amount of long-term waste generated should be stored at Lucas Heights in Sydney, where it is produced, thus avoiding the problem of transport altogether, they argue.
Councillor Jade Kudrenko, a member of the Greens, suggested to her fellow aldermen that the issues, particularly in relation to the impact on emergency services, should be put on the agenda for council’s next committee meeting.
Cr Eli Melky wanted to know what else the deputation would like council to do.
BNI spokesperson Lauren Mellor suggested council could also write to the Federal Government to ask when local governments will be consulted on the issues. (Minister Ferguson has said that as soon as the litigation concludes, he will “consult widely with the parties that have rights, interests or legitimate expectations with respect to any nomination”.) She also suggested that council could push for the Local Government Association of the NT (LGANT) to raise the issues with the Federal Government  and that the council could consider itself the formation of a committee to oppose the waste facility.
 
Pictured, above left: The anti-nuclear lobby in Alice is persistent and well-organised. Here they take part in a festival parade in 2009. From the Alice News archive.

Engineers rule?

The intersection looking east,  with the child care centre on the left.  

By KIERAN FINNANE

 
“This council shouldn’t in any way, shape or form, question an engineer, we should take the advice as provided.”
So said Councillor Chansey Paech on the issue of the proposed roundabout at the intersection of Undoolya Road and Sturt Terrace.
He also expressed his belief that “the majority” of people in “that street” – Sturt Terrace? – support the proposal, despite no clear evidence before him. Of the four responses the council’s letter drop on the issue, three opposed the proposal (see previous report).
Cr Paech was picking up on the cues from council’s Director of Technical Services Greg Buxton and CEO Rex Mooney.
They both stressed in the discussion at last night’s meeting the sequence of events leading to the roundabout proposal: approval by the DCA of a child care centre located on the north-eastern corner of the intersection despite the council’s opposition; the safety issues arising; the solution proposed by the traffic management engineers council then called in; the successful second round application for $300,000 worth of Black Spot funding from the Commonwealth.
“We sought that funding at the direction of this chamber,” said Mr Buxton.
“We’ve done as much as we can to get the proposal on the table before you,” said Mr Mooney.
Meanwhile, council has gone a step further, proposing to adopt a 40kmh speed limit across the Wills Terrace causeway, which feeds traffic from the CBD into Eastside, once the roundabout is built.
Would the speed restriction and the erection of crash barriers not take care of the child care centre safety issue, Cr Eli Melky wanted to know. This was left hanging.
Mayor Damien Ryan, who at the committee meeting had queried the community’s support for the roundabout, appeared to have resolved this concern in his own mind. He did however raise the issue of pedestrians crossing the intersection. Roundabouts are designed to keep vehicular traffic flowing which can be a problem for pedestrians. A lot of people living in Eastside do walk into and back from town, he pointed out. He wanted to ensure that there would be a crossing giving them right of way before council signs off on the project.
Mr Buxton said he would review the proposal, examining the options of a “wombat” crossing (like the one on Gregory Terrace between Coles and Kmart) and traffic islands.
Cr Jade Kudrenko also wanted to see cyclists’ needs taken into account.
 
COMMENT: If you ask an engineer to examine a proposal, he is likely to come up with an engineered solution. If an urban planner had been asked, a quite different solution may have been proposed.
Traffic management engineers are being called upon to develop a report for the CBD. This is something that emerged from confidential consideration for the first time in last night’s meeting and no discussion of the issues was heard. Crs Kundrenko and Paech drew attention to the absence of the relevant reports in the papers. They will be supplied at next month’s committee meeting. An issue to keep an eye on.
 

Below: Children playing at the child care centre. Their safety is at issue.  

A street by any other name …

Alice Springs Town Council last night approved new street names proposed for the Mt John subdivision, two of them being Arrernte words honouring past traditional owners of the area.
The phonetic pronunciation of these words will be part of the signage and this practice will be adopted for all future street name signage.
The names are Werlatye Court (pronounced Wool-at-ya) and Irrampenye Court (pronounced Irrr-ram-pen-ya).
‘Werlatye’ means ‘woman’ in Arrernte, according to the council papers. Likewise ‘Irrampenye’ means man.
The names go back as far as the oral history records and refer to the ancestors of the present day senior custodians and traditional owners, according to the papers.
The Mt John subdivision is being developed by a commercial entity associated with the native title holders’ corporation, Lhere Artepe Aboriginal Corporation.
The third street name is ‘MacConochie’, an extension  of an existing street by the same name.

Alice job market down but not out

By ERWIN CHLANDA
 
An Alice Springs labour hire company says business is down compared to a year ago and job seekers outnumber available positions about five to one, says Chris Jackson, of Centre Labourforce and Recruitment NT.
Before the downturn 150 people a week were contracted through the firm, she says.
That figure is now down to between 80 and 100.
And employers seeking to fill vacancies through CLF now number around five to 10 a week, compared to 25 a year ago.
Ms Jackson says a typical mix of weekly job applicants is 25 locals and 15 backpackers.
She says the service provided by her company suits short-term positions – putting up the K-Mart sails is one example – and people wanting to first try out a job, both workers and employers.
The firm contracts the workers – Ms Jackson calls them contractors – and administers their wages, payroll, super, workers comp and tax.
The business contracting the contractor gets an invoice weekly while the contractor is working.  If they want to take the contractor on as an employee they are charged a negotiated fee. If the business wants them to do recruiting for a position the commission is 5% of the wages below $50,000 a year, says Ms Jackson.
The firm does not qualify for government subsidies paid to other job network agencies.
If the job works out, from the view point of the employer as well as the contractor’s, then he can become an employee of the business.
If not the contractor would remain part of the firm’s labour force and, if possible, be re-deployed on other projects.
Ms Jackson says she rarely uses conventional advertising, on the web and print, because it attracts mostly people from overseas looking for 457 or holiday working visas.
It’s not possible to adequately assess the suitability of these people, says Ms Jackson.
She rather relies on people “coming through the door,” word of mouth and a network of 28 similar agencies around Australia.
She says the cost of housing in Alice Springs is a major problem for people from outside the town, but a good number of applicants already live here.