Council shoots Anzac precinct gallery down in flames


2589 council 15:10:18 OK

AT TONIGHT’S Council meeting (from left) Councillors Catherine Satour, Jimmy Cocking, Matt Paterson and Eli Melky. In the gallery, Doris Stuart (light cardigan) and Harold Furber (with hat). BELOW: Mrs Stuart.

2589 Doris Stuart OKBy ERWIN CHLANDA
The Town Council tonight rejected unanimously what amounts to a letter of demand from the NT Government to hand over Anzac Oval.
The letter, signed by MLA for Braitling Dale Wakefield and Minister for Culture Lauren Moss, is asking for the “transition the Anzac Precinct site” to the government “to allow for the development of the National Aboriginal Art Gallery”.
They say the site would be made up by the Anzac Oval, which is owned by the council, and the old Anzac Hill school site, which is owed by the government.
All eight elected members who were present at the committee meeting, including Mayor Damien Ryan, voted against the five points in the letter.
As the issue could be regarded as an urgent matter, CEO Rex Mooney said he was empowered to treat the vote as final decision without it having to be put before the ordinary meeting in two weeks’ time.
Cr Marli Banks was absent on annual leave.
Cr Matt Paterson said he was casting a no vote “reluctantly” but he didn’t want it to be a seven to one vote.
The other councillors left no doubt about their outrage over the government’s handling of the gallery plan.
Cr Jamie de Brenni was chairing the debate. He said the council tried to guide the government, “how to do it, how to move forward. I don’t see our recommendations here,” referring to the letter from the Ministers.
“I personally feel we reject all five points.”
Cr Jimmy Cocking said the government, in its consultation, was looking “for the yes people”. He objected to the suggestion of running the gallery planning similar to the “reference group established to provide cultural advice on the development of Parrtjima”.
His comment came after earlier in the meeting Doris Stuart, one of the town’s most senior elders, had made an impassioned plea for “the right person, not anyone with a black face” to be consulted: “Here you go, here is your money.”
Mayor Ryan said: “We set up a meeting, asking to work with the government. We had the meeting, these are the key points they raised, it was released to the press half an hour after we received the letter.
“I don’t accept any of the points raised in this. I don’t accept the terms and conditions.”
Cr Glen Auricht was fuming: “They have completely ignored us as a council, speaking for the community.
“They actually demand that we give up the oval for them to do what they like, before there are any plans, any consideration of what the ratepayers want.
“Just wiping out that big car park there, across Wills Terrace which is used a lot by people attending the Catholic Church and other functions … for the seniors group, for the people going shopping.”
He said “we need to consult with the traditional owners – Mrs Stuart, Harold Furber” who also spoke earlier in the meeting.
About the government Cr Auricht said: “I just don’t believe a word they are saying. They are just trying to put as up against the wall to be shot by everybody.”
“There is no real vision,” said Cr Jacinta Price. “This letter tells us that it’s basically council’s fault not having put up any other locations on the table. But their very own steering committee had already presented recommendations at the very beginning of all of this.
“We’ll have a rush job instead of something significant and meaningful – a wonderful icon for the whole of Australia.”
Cr Catherine Satour she had expressed support for the gallery to be in Alice Springs, but she is against the use of Anzac Oval.
The five points proposed by Ministers Wakefield and Moss include “considerable car parking and open green space and [the precinct] will be available for events and general community enjoyment”.
Rugby league and union would get an alternative site “subject to that transitioning of the Anzac Precinct to the NT Government”.
“I wonder what’s going to be in the next letter,” concluded one Councillor.
UPDATE Oct 17, 9.38am
Opposition Leader Gary Higgins provided the following statement:–
The Labor government’s heavy-handed approach to the National Aboriginal Art Gallery has failed spectacularly and further plunged the project into uncertainty.
The unanimous vote of Alice Springs Town Council reinforces the sharp divide between the government and the local community.
This gallery belongs in Alice Springs, but due to the mismanagement of two Ministers, South Australia is forging ahead with its plans.
I continue to be concerned about this Labor Government’s bully boy tactics and its arrogant “we know better” approach to Territory projects.
The threat of compulsory acquisition reeks of desperation as Labor tries to fix its failed attempt to deliver what should be an iconic landmark for Alice Springs and the nation.
The Territory Opposition supports this project being built in Alice Springs, not Adelaide and not anywhere else in Australia. The Northern Territory is the rightful home of this gallery.


  1. I congratulate the councillors for their demonstrated commitment to principles, to what is best for their community, and with support from the community.
    With inadequate public information, such rejection is the best decision for government.
    Good government for good decisions requires full, open, lengthy and public discussions of issues long before decisions to be made.
    For far too long various NT governments have regularly demonstrated their lack of this ability.
    Voters in the NT need ensure each MLA understands clearly they are elected, or rejected, by their electorate, not their party.

  2. Just another moment in the most inept and arrogant handling of a project proposal I have ever encountered.
    At this place in time we have to ask ourselves if the intent to deliver a gallery was ever there. Was it simply smoke and mirrors, covering no real intention to commit funds?
    What else could it be when, if the intent was genuine, the NT Government could resolve the issues with council with one meeting!
    In that meeting all they must do is commit to working “with” council on the project design and implementation, as has been done on many previous occasions.
    What is so dammed hard about that?
    Unless either are completely arrogant, just plain stupid or a totally inept combination of both.
    Whatever it is, one thing is absolutely for certain this project, if there ever was one, is now very much at risk!
    So where are you, local Labor people?
    Where are our local Members?
    Where the bloody hell are you?
    If you believe in us, in Alice Springs and its future just walk into council and resolve this issue, cooperatively!
    Yes, today!
    If you can’t bring yourselves to do that, then you deserve to be condemned by your community.
    What a bloody disgrace!

  3. The council have finally found some intestinal fortitude, well done to all.
    Now is the time for the government to start afresh with some genuine consultations, some constructive ideas and plans and a desire to do what they are elected to do, govern for the community.
    Has this whole incompetent fiasco been the elected government as such or is the tale wagging the dog as has been happening for years? The beauracts running the place like the famous Yes, Minister?

  4. Steve I think you’re right. Both completely arrogant and plain stupid just like the previous government. It’s time we stopped voting for either of these inept parties.

  5. The Treasurer, Nicole Manison, has just released a “STATEMENT” declaring: “The Northern Territory is still $500 million out of pocket every year despite the Federal Government’s proposed new legislation on GST distribution.
    “This legislation protects us from future cuts, but does nothing to restore the $500 million less GST revenue we have lost from Canberra.
    “That’s $500 million less for police, teachers and nurses – and this continues to hurt us.”
    Well, if the NT’s economic circumstances are now so dire, with so much less money available for essential services, does the NT Government have the $50 million to spare (let alone any extra funding) to spend on a National Aboriginal Art Gallery for which there is no actual plan and no substance to the claims made for its supposed economic benefit?
    Notwithstanding its massive majority in the NT Legislative Assembly, this is a government that appears to be floundering with no real idea of what to do.
    I think we’re in a lot more trouble than most of us realise.

  6. Well done to the town council for your decision. The government now needs to talk to Doris Stuart and Harold Furber to see the plans for the Cultural Centre and Art Gallery that are already in place.

  7. Absurdity piled on absurdity.
    First we have a government, proposing to build an Indigenous art gallery without reference to the Aboriginal custodians of the land they propose to use, and furthermore with apparently no consideration of how they might gain a consensus from the hundreds of groups of Indigenous people across the nation so as to give the “national” tag some credibility.
    Secondly we have the absurdity of trying to force the local council to come on board and accept a site which is not only unacceptable to the traditional owners, but also to a large but as yet unknown properly ascertained proportion of ratepayers; which has also been chosen on the basis of dubious reasoning.
    How long can this schemozzle keep running?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here